A review by bluejayreads
A Deadly Education by Naomi Novik

dark tense medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Character
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? It's complicated
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

5.0

This was already on my reading list, but when I realized the author was the same author who wrote Spinning Silver, it jumped to the top of the list. And it was 100% worth it. 

I'm going to start here with an apology. I hate when people compare books to the Harry Potter series, not in the least because Harry Potter is just not that great. (I will do a full post on this eventually but for now please bear with me.) So it is with the deepest apologies that I call A Deadly Education "Harry Potter but darker and much, much better." 

You want a magical school? I give you the Scholomance. You want a magical school with halls that move on their own? I'll do you one better: A magical school that is sentient to some degree, warps space for its own purposes, will only put classrooms and staircases in a particular place if you believe they will be there hard enough, and is literally built inside a magical void. 

You want a powerful protagonist? I give you El, the protagonist, whose magic specialty means that defending herself with magic could mean killing everyone in the Scholomance. You want a protagonist with interesting heritage and a prophecy about them? I'll do you one better: El's mother is famous for her magical ability, and El's own extended family tried to kill her due to a prophecy about her. 

You want a constant sense of danger even on school grounds? The Scholomance is infested with malevolent monsters, to the point where every bite has to be checked for poison, every cafeteria table has to be inspected for monsters, and going to the bathroom alone is a death sentence. There are no teachers because it isn't needed - if you don't learn, you die. You only have an 80% chance of surviving the Scholomance, but only a 40% chance of surviving the monsters out in the world without the training the Scholomance gives you. The Scholomance may be hellish but it's everyone's best shot. 

El herself is fantastic. She doesn't know why people don't like her on sight, but she hides under layers of anger and sarcasm and biting ... I was going to say biting wit, but it's not even witty, it's just biting but I enjoyed it. She is prickly and unfriendly but so damn relatable at times and the kind of absurdly-powerful-but-always-underestimated that I absolutely love. Plus she has so much character growth in this story and I can't wait to see where she goes in the rest of the series. 

Admittedly, this book is not perfect. There is a ton of exposition dumped in to explain the world, the way the Scholomance and the magical world works, and El's backstory. It did slow the action and very much felt like an info-dump. I found it to be interesting info, and I was intrigued enough by the world that it didn't interrupt my enjoyment of the story. I do recognize, though, that if you're not engaged enough in the world, it will come across as really boring and poorly paced. 

I cannot say enough good things about this world, this magic system, this magic school, everything. It's dark, violent, magical, and real, with all the grittiness of a bunch of high schoolers cloistered in a sentient school where at least 20% of them will die before graduation and the dark whimsy of a magic system that would just as soon drain you dry and toss aside your desiccated corpse as help you create a magic mirror.  Classism and privilege are major themes and they fit seamlessly into the story. I can't say too much more without spoilers - this story unfolds like a black rose, each petal opening and revealing more darkness and danger within. And it deserves to be read without spoilers. It deserves to be experienced as fully and wonderfully as it exists - unapologetic, dark, enthralling, full of beautiful and hideous magic.  
Expand filter menu Content Warnings