Scan barcode
A review by octavia_cade
The Death of Nature: Women, Ecology, and the Scientific Revolution by Carolyn Merchant
3.0
I'm so glad this is over.
That sounds like a terrible thing to say, because this is in many ways an excellent book. The research is incredibly thorough. And the argument itself is fascinating: that the history of science allows us to track changing attitudes towards nature, and that those attitudes have knock-on consequences for political and economic thought, and that they have particular consequences for the treatment of women. Merchant therefore observes, in frequently exhaustive detail, the similarity of approach to both nature and women during the Scientific Revolution, and how attitudes to the two often moved in synch.
She is very, very convincing, and I would love to have given this book four stars, because the quality of the research deserves that at least. It's just the book is so very, very dull. Well, not dull exactly. It is dry. It took me weeks to get through, a little a day, and even then I had to reread at least half the paragraphs at least twice, because I'd space out halfway through and go looking for water. I realise that academic prose is not easy, and I have certainly inflicted my terrible share of it, but that doesn't make it any better to read. In fact, what made it worse was that every so often there'd be several pages that were genuinely, appealingly readable, just plain readable, and I'd perk up for all of five minutes before being catapulted back into stodge.
It is truly a fascinating argument, buried underneath the soporific prose. If only I could bear to read it again... but I can't. I'm sorry, once is enough.
That sounds like a terrible thing to say, because this is in many ways an excellent book. The research is incredibly thorough. And the argument itself is fascinating: that the history of science allows us to track changing attitudes towards nature, and that those attitudes have knock-on consequences for political and economic thought, and that they have particular consequences for the treatment of women. Merchant therefore observes, in frequently exhaustive detail, the similarity of approach to both nature and women during the Scientific Revolution, and how attitudes to the two often moved in synch.
She is very, very convincing, and I would love to have given this book four stars, because the quality of the research deserves that at least. It's just the book is so very, very dull. Well, not dull exactly. It is dry. It took me weeks to get through, a little a day, and even then I had to reread at least half the paragraphs at least twice, because I'd space out halfway through and go looking for water. I realise that academic prose is not easy, and I have certainly inflicted my terrible share of it, but that doesn't make it any better to read. In fact, what made it worse was that every so often there'd be several pages that were genuinely, appealingly readable, just plain readable, and I'd perk up for all of five minutes before being catapulted back into stodge.
It is truly a fascinating argument, buried underneath the soporific prose. If only I could bear to read it again... but I can't. I'm sorry, once is enough.