You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.
Take a photo of a barcode or cover
aotora 's review for:
Warriors Super Edition: Tigerheart's Shadow
by Erin Hunter
2022
I decided to come back to this book after reading TBC where Tigerstar has a little bit more of a presence and ... I actually liked it much more than I did when I first read it back in 2020.
There are still some flaws in this book, mainly how annoying both Dovewing and Tigerheart can be, but it's still a good book. It's yet another travelling heavy book and we sadly don't get to see apprenticeship/kithood of Tigerheart which was rather disappointing. I would much rather read a book that is over 500 pages long but it includes those two things than a 400 page book where half of it is just.... travelling and hunting and existing. I also love Blaze, Cinammon and Ant - too bad that they become background characters after this book and they barely do anything after this one. They are still amazing though and I enjoyed seeing them learning about warriors and their way of living.
2020
This one was the next on the list of SE's I still have to read and ... I didn't like this one. This one had to be my least favourite one so far. I disliked it even more than I disliked Bluestar's prophecy.
The beginning and end were boring, the middle where they lived with guardian cats got repetitive aside from them fighting foxes and leading them to the traps - I actually enjoyed that scene a lot.
I liked Spire and Blaze but I wasn't a fan of Tigerheart or Dovewing, they bickered a lot, Dovewing could be needlessly annoying and angry, Tigerheart could be selfish and how he started hammer warrior ways and code down every guardian cat's throat- I wished that for once Fog would turn out not to be a treat but just a rouge that wanted to live and let live, but no- of course she wanted to take over their place and their prey and of course they had to establish borders and fight for them just like warriors- even though they lived perfectly chill lives without them up to that point.
It was boring, it was repetitive and the main two characters including the one about who this book is were boring and annoying. I didn't like this one, it's my least favourite one so far and I don't think that I will be picking this one up again any time soon.
I decided to come back to this book after reading TBC where Tigerstar has a little bit more of a presence and ... I actually liked it much more than I did when I first read it back in 2020.
There are still some flaws in this book, mainly how annoying both Dovewing and Tigerheart can be, but it's still a good book. It's yet another travelling heavy book and we sadly don't get to see apprenticeship/kithood of Tigerheart which was rather disappointing. I would much rather read a book that is over 500 pages long but it includes those two things than a 400 page book where half of it is just.... travelling and hunting and existing. I also love Blaze, Cinammon and Ant - too bad that they become background characters after this book and they barely do anything after this one. They are still amazing though and I enjoyed seeing them learning about warriors and their way of living.
2020
This one was the next on the list of SE's I still have to read and ... I didn't like this one. This one had to be my least favourite one so far. I disliked it even more than I disliked Bluestar's prophecy.
The beginning and end were boring, the middle where they lived with guardian cats got repetitive aside from them fighting foxes and leading them to the traps - I actually enjoyed that scene a lot.
I liked Spire and Blaze but I wasn't a fan of Tigerheart or Dovewing, they bickered a lot, Dovewing could be needlessly annoying and angry, Tigerheart could be selfish and how he started hammer warrior ways and code down every guardian cat's throat- I wished that for once Fog would turn out not to be a treat but just a rouge that wanted to live and let live, but no- of course she wanted to take over their place and their prey and of course they had to establish borders and fight for them just like warriors- even though they lived perfectly chill lives without them up to that point.
It was boring, it was repetitive and the main two characters including the one about who this book is were boring and annoying. I didn't like this one, it's my least favourite one so far and I don't think that I will be picking this one up again any time soon.