xolotlll 's review for:

4.0

Ironically, its own attempts to weave a single theme leave it without a strong sense of coherence or unity - Hofstadter himself admits that the point is obscured here, which is apparently why he wrote the follow-up. This book is fun and unique, but undeniably self-indulgent and occasionally quite tedious. It's great to see such a wide synthesis of ideas, but the connections Hofstadter makes are often a stretch - if you flick through the book, you'll see all sorts of provocative diagrams and images, but their relevance is usually marginal, strained or trivial.