lexistwick 's review for:

The Book of Witching by C.J. Cooke

3.5

adventurous dark mysterious tense slow-paced

Plot or Character Driven: A mix

Strong character development: Complicated

Loveable characters: Complicated

Diverse cast of characters: No

Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

---

C.J. Cooke’s The Book of Witching is an ambitious and immersive tale that connects two women living 400 years apart, their lives bound by a mysterious and seemingly malevolent book. Equal parts historical fiction and modern mystery, it offers a haunting exploration of the witch trials and the cultural forces that shaped them.

What stands out most is Cooke’s meticulous research, which shines particularly in the older sections of the story. The use of old language, religious worldviews, and the justice systems of the time creates a vivid and unsettling portrait of history.

Readers with a curiosity for the witch trials or the true history of the period will find this aspect deeply rewarding, and I highly recommend the author’s note for its insights into the research underpinning the narrative. It felt like a journey into the heart of a community grappling with fear, power, and persecution.

The book’s pacing, however, might challenge some readers. The first half unfolds slowly, lingering on atmosphere and historical detail, before the plot gains momentum in the latter sections. While the modern timeline provides a welcome contrast to the older language and settings, it sometimes feels like it exists primarily to keep the story moving rather than to contribute meaningfully to the larger themes.

Despite this, The Book of Witching is a compelling read for those who appreciate stories that blur the lines between past and present. It’s a book steeped in atmosphere, rich with historical detail, and unafraid to delve into the darker corners of justice and belief. For writers, it’s a fascinating example of how to weave historical research into fiction, using language and worldview to transport readers to another time.

While the pacing might not be for everyone, the depth of historical authenticity and the chilling mystery at the book’s heart make The Book of Witching worth the journey—especially for those who love stories that unearth hidden histories and offer a glimpse into the fears and faiths that shaped our past.