atagarev 's review for:

The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes by Arthur Conan Doyle
4.0

I hadn't read any of the Sherlock Holmes short stories since I was a kid. I wasn't sure what to expect now as an adult but they turned out to still be quite enjoyable. Holmes is not a very likable character and I found Watson's awestruck attitude a little tiresome but it managed to stick to a good balance of making Holmes impressive yet not quite perfect.

The stories themselves were somewhat predictable but interesting and short enough to keep my attention. I was worried about how the themes have aged but Holmes keeps enough of an air of mystery about his beliefs that he comes across as quite progressive for his time.

I didn't find any individual stories standing out as exceptionally good or particularly bad. In fact, the collection is uncommonly consistent in its quality.