A review by kashby
Elantris: Tenth Anniversary Author's Definitive Edition by Brandon Sanderson

dark slow-paced

2.0

elantris reads very much like a debut novel from someone who is very inspired and has a lot to say. it’s slightly dense and i hate saying this but preachy with some Old Man Fantasy™️ energy but sanderson’s worst book is a lot of authors’s best. i read the first part on print and it took about a week and a half but i read the rest on graphic audio and it was easier to get through.

it’s written very different from sanderson’s other books. instead of plot twists and surprises, elantris is more constantly suspenseful, where you’re watching as plans slowly crumble and plotlines cross over at the least convenient times. i was never truly shocked reading this, which is an emotion i feel a lot while reading sanderson, unless the plot twist is something that doesn’t make sense (no spoilers but some of the plot choices are not something that i think sanderson would write today). it’s also a lot darker than his current books. oathbringer is sanderson’s book that i would say is equally as intense but oathbringer feels very hopeful while elantris is much more despondent. it’s not frighting and i wouldn’t classify it as a horror book but it’s definitely very dark.

i think this book is written slightly like a dnd campaign in the sense that when we begin a scene, sometimes the vibes are “this is this person. this is who they’re related to and a quirk about them. this is the next person and who they’re related to and a quirk about them.” which honestly made the book drag a lot. i understand trying to give the side characters different personalities but i had a hard time telling them apart because they all had the same type of speaking tone. the graphic audio helped a lot because the different side characters have different voices but the actors did a lot of heavy lifting on that front. the plot was amazing and creative and interesting but i could tell it was his first published novel. i would be very interested in a rewrite of this book with  sanderson’s current knowledge.
Expand filter menu Content Warnings