liralen's profile picture

liralen 's review for:

The Icarus Girl by Helen Oyeyemi
3.0

Interesting. Much like Jessy's desire to know the basics of British fairytales so that she can understand her classmates better, I could have used a primer on Yoruba mythology—not necessary to understand the shape of the book, but, you know. Curiosity! (I knew a tiny bit about twin superstition in parts of Africa—stemming, I'm afraid, from reading [b:The Power Of One|4936988|The Power Of One|Bryce Courtenay|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1223330200l/4936988._SX50_.jpg|649656] when I was in high school—but now I'm curious about how those superstitions and myths and fairytales translate across borders and cultures and subcultures; South Africa is a long way from Nigeria.)

The book picked up for me in the second half—though I'm not sure I could really tell you why—before crash-landing at the end. I could have used a bit more movement throughout, I think: it's not long before TillyTilly is an uneasy force but much longer before anything happens to jar Jessy out of...complacency? Unwillingness to push back? And I am curious, in retrospect, about what it means that Jessy's problems (fear, screaming) start before TillyTilly's appearance.

Still, it captures a unique intersection of childhood—that sense of possibility combined with being, to adults, an unreliable narrator just by dint of one's age.