Scan barcode
A review by takara_reads
The Most Wonderful Crime of the Year by Ally Carter
5.0
The Most Wonderful Crime of the Year is an irresistible holiday mystery with a dash of enemies-to-lovers romance, perfect for fans of locked-room puzzles and snowy settings. Alice Eames expertly crafts a tale full of twists, turns, and simmering chemistry, making it a standout in the cozy mystery genre.
The story begins when Maggie Chase, a cozy mystery author who prides herself on her logical mind, and Ethan Wyatt, a cocky thriller writer, are both summoned to the remote English estate of Eleanor Ashley, the “Duchess of Death” and the most famous mystery writer in the world. Eleanor is a living legend, known for her ingenious plots—and her reclusive nature. But when she vanishes from her locked bedroom during a Christmas snowstorm, Maggie and Ethan are drawn into a high-stakes game of wits. Is Eleanor in danger, or is this a cleverly staged mystery meant to test their mettle?
Maggie and Ethan are a delightfully mismatched pair. Maggie’s sharp tongue and disdain for Ethan’s smugness make their interactions crackle with tension. Ethan, in turn, basks in Maggie’s irritation while subtly proving that he’s more than just a handsome face. As the story progresses, their banter evolves into reluctant trust—and something more—as they work together to untangle the clues Eleanor left behind.
The locked-room mystery is brilliantly executed, with enough red herrings to keep readers guessing. The snowbound mansion setting is a character in its own right, full of hidden passageways, eerie decor, and the perfect amount of holiday charm to offset the growing sense of danger. The supporting cast—a group of colorful, suspicious house guests—adds layers to the mystery and keeps tensions high as Maggie and Ethan race against time.
What makes this novel truly sparkle is Eames’ ability to balance humor, romance, and suspense. Maggie and Ethan’s budding relationship never overshadows the central mystery but adds warmth to the chilling stakes. The witty dialogue, clever plotting, and holiday atmosphere make this a compulsively readable book that’s as fun as it is smart.
The Most Wonderful Crime of the Year is a must-read for anyone who loves classic whodunits with a modern twist, sparkling banter, and a touch of Christmas magic. Alice Eames delivers a sleigh full of surprises, making this a perfect addition to your holiday reading list.