A review by laurla
Fool's Gold by Juliet Blackwell

found the story on the authors website. https://julietblackwell.net/pdfs/fools-gold.pdf

Lily wakes up to a satyr on her couch that oscar brought home. she leaves oscar alone to deal with returning the satyr and when she returns, she ends up having to help oscar remove the reward he asked for that turns out to be a curse instead.