You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.
Take a photo of a barcode or cover
moonrattle 's review for:
Lone Women
by Victor LaValle
adventurous
dark
mysterious
tense
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Plot
Strong character development:
No
Loveable characters:
No
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
The premise of Lone Women by Victor Lavalle promises a very unique plot and tackles a historical time and place from an angle that can be interesting, exploring the black female homesteaders. The premise of this book is very interesting and I am a sucker for magical realism, particularly if it takes a gothic turn. And to be fair, the opening chapters deliver intrigue and promise, immediately immersing the reader in the story of Adelaide, a woman who abruptly leaves her California home to homestead in the remote wilderness of Montana. With her, she carries a mysterious trunk, the contents of which are both literal and metaphorical representations of her burdens and baggage. This setup teases a compelling exploration of themes like loneliness, the human need for belonging, the pursuit of a fresh start, and the shadow of generational trauma and curses.
Adelaide's journey and the secrets she guards are engaging enough to sustain momentum, and really, I think, that was all I needed. However, as the narrative progresses, it becomes apparent that Lavalle may have taken on more than he could effectively weave together. The book introduces a wide array of characters and plotlines, but many remain underdeveloped, leaving the story feeling scattered and superficial. This lack of focus detracts from the thematic depth that could have been explored more fully.
While magical realism and gothic often thrives on subtlety and is usually grounded psychological realism, Lone Women leans heavily into the fantastical without adequately establishing the world or the rules that govern it, and the characters are flat and do not provide interesting psychological profiles with one or two of the Mudges getting the closest. The absence of detailed world-building and the lack of psychological depth in the characters undermine the potential for the story to achieve the archetypal or mythical resonance that makes magical realism truly shine. Instead, the fantastical elements dominate without sufficient grounding, making them feel more arbitrary than awe-inspiring.
Ultimately, while the novel offers an intriguing premise and moments of genuine enjoyment, it struggles under the weight of its own ambitions. The result is a story that feels overstuffed and undercooked, and left me yearning for a deeper connection to its characters, its themes, and its world.
Adelaide's journey and the secrets she guards are engaging enough to sustain momentum, and really, I think, that was all I needed. However, as the narrative progresses, it becomes apparent that Lavalle may have taken on more than he could effectively weave together. The book introduces a wide array of characters and plotlines, but many remain underdeveloped, leaving the story feeling scattered and superficial. This lack of focus detracts from the thematic depth that could have been explored more fully.
While magical realism and gothic often thrives on subtlety and is usually grounded psychological realism, Lone Women leans heavily into the fantastical without adequately establishing the world or the rules that govern it, and the characters are flat and do not provide interesting psychological profiles with one or two of the Mudges getting the closest. The absence of detailed world-building and the lack of psychological depth in the characters undermine the potential for the story to achieve the archetypal or mythical resonance that makes magical realism truly shine. Instead, the fantastical elements dominate without sufficient grounding, making them feel more arbitrary than awe-inspiring.
Ultimately, while the novel offers an intriguing premise and moments of genuine enjoyment, it struggles under the weight of its own ambitions. The result is a story that feels overstuffed and undercooked, and left me yearning for a deeper connection to its characters, its themes, and its world.