A review by bargainbinkazbrekker
Don't Let the Forest In by C.G. Drews

3.0

Thank you to Macmillan Children's Publishing Group and NetGalley for providing me with an e-arc in exchange for an honest review!

I thoroughly enjoyed the horror elements of this book, the body horror reminded me of hell followed with us by A.J. White; the descriptions were gruesomely and wonderfully descriptive and well written, as well as the general horror elements that weren’t body horror. I think the horror was the strongest part of this novel.

 But alas, the horror was (to my surprise) not the main focus. The bulk of the story was focused on Andrew and Thomas’s relationship and Andrew's identity. Had this been marketed as more of a romance and self exploration novel with elements of horror, I wouldn't have been so caught off guard. I was getting tired of the constant descriptions of Thomas, it felt like every other sentence was Thomas this and Thomas that, to a point that I genuinely didn’t have an idea who Andrew was outside of Thomas. I get that's sort of the point but I think it would’ve been nice to have a starting point where we compare and contrast Andrew at the beginning vs the end with his obsession with Thomas but the very first chapter he’s already completely obsessed. (A break would’ve been nice as well, I was actually getting irked with how much of Andrew's narration was just Thomas).

I also felt as though the story progressed too slowly. I got more than 50% of the way through and only two major things had happened, one at the very beginning and one right after half way, and everything in between was so slow and repetitive. Every night and every morning followed a similar pattern until it would be broken up by a major event before it would start to fall back into that pattern again. There were also some elements and plot points that were mentioned and then just completely dropped? Thomas’s parents and the following investigation? Hardly mentioned outside of the first few chapters. The enforcement of not sneaking out at night by the school staff? Never actually (conveniently) happens.

In summary, I think marketing this as primarily a horror novel was a bit of a disservice to the book. I think it would be better and more true to the actual story for it to be marketed as a romance with horror elements. I loved the horror elements, they were the best parts for me, but I got a bit sick of the romance and main dynamic because of how overwritten I felt the relationship and descriptions was. The writing, for me, was beautiful for the non romance elements. I may reread it once it's released and see how I feel knowing and not expecting it to be a horror book first and romance second. I would recommend this to body horror lovers, darker queer romance appreciators, and people who enjoy flowery prose.