A review by rubyredders
As Good As Dead by Holly Jackson

adventurous dark emotional mysterious tense medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

5.0

The start took a while to pick up but by 50% this book had me flipping pages eyes boggled.

I genuinely did NOT see the book taking the turns it did. I felt so damn smart like I know who
the DT killer is
it's so obvious but Holly Jackson said you thought I'd make it so easy and gave me emotional whiplash for 300 odd pages.

Poor Pip really goes through it this whole series and this book really lets that sink in for you. You feel the PTSD she is living with, a constant under layer of grief and anxiety following her, which really helped immerse me in the story. 

The way this manages to circle back to elements from the first story surprised me as I would NOT have guessed that was in the cards at all. Bit sad we didnt get a proper resolution to the Charlie Green storyline from the previous book especially with Pip wanting so badly to talk to him again in the first part of this story but I can understand why the focus dropped off of him as the story progressed.

I could see this book being really divisive for previous readers as it takes a decisively different turn than the previous two books in the series but for my part I was hooked. 

I would've preferred to have seen more of Max trial than just a brief headline at the end and sacrificed some of the alibi/set up but given how much went down in the book I understand the authors decision not go tthere


Needless to say Team Pip and Ravi but also Team Get This Girl A Therapist.
Expand filter menu Content Warnings