You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.

cthgrcia's profile picture

cthgrcia 's review for:

Why We Broke Up by Daniel Handler
5.0

I remember reading this as a teenager back when I was in high school and I still recall how I enjoyed this. I think a huge part of my enjoyment is to be credited on Maria Kalman’s illustrations. The illustrations are integral to the narrative, adding an extra layer of emotion and depth to the story. They are not just embellishments but part of the storytelling, making the reading experience more immersive.

This book is a poignant and uniquely structured young adult novel. It's a deep dive into the complexities of teenage love and heartbreak, told through the narrative of Min Green as she recounts the reasons behind her breakup with Ed Slaterton. The book is styled as a long letter from Min to Ed, accompanied by illustrations of items that she is returning to him, each representing a moment in their relationship. This creative format sets the book apart, as each item serves as a catalyst for Min's memories and reflections.

Handler’s writing is both sharp and tender, capturing the intense emotions and drama of teenage relationships. The character of Min is particularly well-drawn; she is relatable, flawed, and deeply human. I think this is what made me even love this more (aside from the fact that I am heartbroken from a breakup with my first teenage boyfriend when I was reading this which made it a tad bit more relatable back then). Her journey through the ups and downs of her relationship with Ed is both heartwarming and heartbreaking.

The supporting characters add richness to the story, providing varied perspectives on love and relationships. The book doesn’t shy away from exploring themes like the pain of first love, the challenge of balancing personal identity with a relationship, and the inevitable growth that comes from heartbreak.

In summary, "Why We Broke Up" is a beautifully written and emotionally resonant novel. It's a realistic portrayal of teenage love, capturing the intensity and transience of first relationships. The unique format, compelling characters, and authentic voice make it a standout in young adult literature.