teddington's profile picture

teddington 's review for:

Yellowfang's Secret by Erin Hunter
3.0

this book sure was Fine. it shares the problem leopardstars honour has where the interesting part (brokenstars reign) is at the very end and gets SO little time before the book's over. people who buy super editions know the books, i dont get why they all feel the need to start right from the beginning with kithood.

also her empath powers are complete garbage. why does she have them? is she a prophecy cat like the three? why don't they use this at all?? why is it forgotten about once she becomes a medicine cat (when its the reason she BECAME a medicine cat)??? cool concept but wasn't executed well at all.

fine book. i like yellowfang so it was bearable.