treiceratops 's review for:

Shiloh by Phyllis Reynolds Naylor

4.0

---

I read this because I never had and it's a Newbery etc etc. I expected to be troubled by the story and saddened by the outcome I expected to occur...I was surprised by everything! I was surprised by the candor and wisdom she gave to the boy, I was surprised by the turn the end took or what I anticipated to be the end (I listened to the audio book). It was simply lovely.