4.5
adventurous dark informative mysterious sad fast-paced

What a bizarre, lurid, and tragic story of people seeking solitude in paradise, who are then destroyed by others’ ideas of what paradise means. The only redeeming quality of each one of the adults involved is their refusal to give up. 

The author’s reliance on primary sources creates a vividness in the telling; you can see what the people are doing, how they are thinking, and, more importantly, how they are obfuscating, all in their own words. The reason these disappearances remain unsolved is the apparent inability of anyone to tell a straight story. 

Most of the internecine hatred appears warranted. Some is resentment born of feelings of territoriality. Some is due to outright provocation. Overall it’s a sad tale of antisocial people who really would have been happier if they’d been able to stay alone. 

Expand filter menu Content Warnings