A review by katyab
Elder Race by Adrian Tchaikovsky

4.0

This was a lovely story, and the dual narrative was really inspired. Something inherently Le-Guin-esque about it, which makes sense given that it's been nominated for the inaugural prize in her name!

I especially loved that magic and the mythical status of certain characters were a matter of perspective and language – I couldn't quite decide if the lost-in-translation aspect of the characters' communication was endearing or devastating, or something else.

The depiction of mental health in this book, specifically clinical depression, was so moving and honest, and one of my favourite things about the story. Balancing emotional investment with the objectivity of anthropological study was particularly interesting, but most of all, the story showed that the systems we have in place can allow us to step away from our emotions (literally, in this case), but not bury them forever; despite the terrible fear of confronting or embracing our darkest feelings, the book is very kind about showing the necessity and catharsis of doing so.

A surprisingly beautiful little tale – Tchaikovsky does it again!