A review by genny
The Sword of Kaigen by M.L. Wang

adventurous dark emotional hopeful sad medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Character
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

5.0

Whew. I thought I knew where this was going
...I fully expected Mamoru to go out into the wider world, a coming-of-age sort of thing where he learns to be critical of power structures and maybe become a vigilante like his mother was
...boy, was I wrong. I still got the commentary on race, politics, etc. that I was looking for, but halfway through the book, something unexpected happened and threw my expectations for the narrative path out the window. I loved where this went, though. The battle scenes were incredible!
The Matsuda Dragon! Mamoru's Whispering Blade! Misaki and Takeru's duel!
I was prepared for the violence in a book about war, but I didn't expect to have such strong feelings for the characters. The emotional journey that Misaki takes is so satisfying. I was holding out hope for the redemption of a certain character, and M. L. Wang delivered
without erasing their accountability or turning it into a cheesy, sudden change of heart. I'm talking about Takeru, of course. I may have melted into a puddle when he and Misaki finally saw each other. Forgive me, the "learning to love" trope gets me every time.
Everything felt intentional; none of the plot twists felt like they were put in there just for shock value.

There were little things that annoyed me. Why keep other "Earth words" like traditional Japanese honorifics but deem our units of time too unbelievable for the setting? I kept consulting the glossary because all the new terms were overwhelming in the beginning, but I did become comfortable enough to rely on context clues eventually. I also got taken aback every time there was a mention of modern technology. It's easy to forget that this isn't set "in the past", Shirojima is just a very traditional village...but that's more of a me problem. I guess I had some sort of bias against visualizing it as a part of the "modern world", even though places like that exist in my own country.

The last chapter was definitely hinting at something more, but I've heard that the Theonite books (taking place in the same setting but with different characters, if I understand correctly) have been discontinued. It may be a strange ending for some, but I'm glad that the Matsudas' story wraps up with a sense of peace.
Expand filter menu Content Warnings