claire_d616's profile picture

claire_d616 's review for:

The Apprentice's Quest by Erin Hunter
2.0

No, Just NO.
i LOVED the Last Hope. i was so good and a perfect way to wrap up the Warrior Cats. But nooooo you just had to keep writing and had to ruin it all. it was not good. oh so somehow, BrambleStar and Squirrelflight, reconciled and have kits. what?? why?? if the hero was a cat that came from a clan and was the protagonist, rather then Firestars great, great, great, grandniece twice removed (you get where im going) it would of been much more exciting.
though the hunters tried to bring new characters in, it was sad because they were all soo boring.
Needlepaw was so anointing, how she never got in trouble but Alderpaw did was beyond me.
it was nowhere near as good as the others andhopefully the next book is better but my hopes are not high.