A review by quechl
A Study in Drowning by Ava Reid

dark emotional mysterious fast-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? No
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.0

I want to start by saying I really enjoyed this book. the writing is absolutely stunning. im fairly certain the most common thing i annotated while reading is something about the prose. Effy as our pov character is interesting and really does make you root for her. the setting was atmospheric and moody, the struggles raw and emotional; reid as an author is most definitely talented and intentional with her craft.
that being said i definitely have a few nitpicks. preston could have been more fleshed out; i wanted more of him, his thoughts and perspective and we just dont see that. i really liked him as a character, but we dont ever really get to see what hes thinking, which i found to be a real shame. the same can be said about the worldbuilding; i LOVE that stuff, and what we do get is really interesting!!! the different saints, local traditions, cultural differences, all of it really tickles me, and its a real shame that the audience (and by that i mean me) wasnt given much chance to read more about it. i want to know about this world, and i felt like it could have been used to further prestons background as well! we had snippets of him telling us sayings, but that was it!! hes supposed to be a passionate lit major!! let him dump info on us!!! i get why it was done, considering the pacing of the book, but its a real shame nonetheless.
and finally, my most major gripe is that the 'twist' was just... predictable. i thought it was going to be a red herring, but no, that was the actual twist, which i found frustrating, especially because effy thinks about the obvious answer like partially once, and then never again. it felt like these clever characters kept missing the clearest answer, and that annoyed me, because the rest of this book really is great. its moody and enticing and tense, and the blurring lines between real and fake is really engaging.

 
honestly i almost wish she left the reality of the fairy king remain a mystery. part of whats enjoyable is that you dont know how much of the story is truely happening. i understand why reid did, but personally i felt like keeping that mystery and dichotomy between the cynic preston and spiritual effy more potent because we the readers dont know the 'objective truth' as preston puts it.
Expand filter menu Content Warnings