ishasih 's review for:

3.0

cannot deny that while reading it, this novel (which is Goethe's first) felt like an important book. the ardent romanticism of a youth who has only recently crossed the thresholds of adolescence seemed strikingly familiar even after all these years. the blood, the vehemence, the angst, and the resignation – story is that many youths across europe committed suicide upon reading the book; and Napoleon himself was deeply smitten by this novel and carried a copy in his pockets when he went to battle in Egypt.

here's the thing: Wether is an impassioned novel, which explains perhaps the many reactions and legends that surround it, and i think it is well written and powerful. notwithstanding, i simply wasn't taken by it as i had expected myself to. perhaps the conditions were't ripe, for i read it under the hot summer sun in what now seems like a flurry, and might have in process missed out on something. even then, perhaps i found it difficult to reconcile with its apparently honest romantic leanings, and like Lotte, i myself said to Werther "be moderate! be moderate!" a few times while reading.

frankly, i do not want to dissuade anyone from reading the novel. it is short and it is also Goethe, for whom i have a deep admiration. but two words of caution: unrequited angst.