You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.
Take a photo of a barcode or cover
jtbolscher 's review for:
The Vanishing Stair
by Maureen Johnson
it was good! on the whole i liked it more than the first one, although they are kinda different in many ways. i think, generally, it was better plotted than the first book, with things actually getting solved while still leaving the overarching mystery. the way it handles certain plot elements from the first book does really make me doubt why the hell they were in there, at least in that way. like she could have scrapped a ton of elements, focus on the current mystery and condense these three books into one, at least so far. plot-wise, it's not like too much has happened to fit into a single novel. anyways i did like the main mystery, and the ending was satisfying and compelling enough as to the why of it all. a solid middle entry into a trilogy whose ending i certainly want to read.
unfortunately i do have a growing distaste for the characters in the story. i'm sorry david, but my prediction fully came true. where he used to be this somewhat weird but ultimately fine guy, i now fully lack sympathy for this man. also the twist was, well, fairly obvious but there's still one final mystery to go. the fact that all of these things take place across what, two months? if that? is absolutely hilarious to me. these people seem far too comfortable with each other for that. also is maureen's shorthand for attractive guy just white, tall and blond? idk man. nate and janelle and vi, while fun, occasionally fall into pantomime (like they have one thing. and that's it. it was funny at first but now its kinda getting tiring). but, on the whole, i do think the group has a cute dynamic. also still seething at the ending of a certain character ! justice for my girl ! anyways.
in the end it's a quick, inoffensive read with a compelling mystery and cute characters. perhaps it leans a bit on its tropes without examining them, and i think there is certainly a better novel hidden within the pages of this series, but it's nonetheless a compulsive mystery in a very atmospheric world.
unfortunately i do have a growing distaste for the characters in the story. i'm sorry david, but my prediction fully came true. where he used to be this somewhat weird but ultimately fine guy, i now fully lack sympathy for this man. also the twist was, well, fairly obvious but there's still one final mystery to go. the fact that all of these things take place across what, two months? if that? is absolutely hilarious to me. these people seem far too comfortable with each other for that. also is maureen's shorthand for attractive guy just white, tall and blond? idk man. nate and janelle and vi, while fun, occasionally fall into pantomime (like they have one thing. and that's it. it was funny at first but now its kinda getting tiring). but, on the whole, i do think the group has a cute dynamic. also still seething at the ending of a certain character ! justice for my girl ! anyways.
in the end it's a quick, inoffensive read with a compelling mystery and cute characters. perhaps it leans a bit on its tropes without examining them, and i think there is certainly a better novel hidden within the pages of this series, but it's nonetheless a compulsive mystery in a very atmospheric world.