Take a photo of a barcode or cover
A review by ketreads
Murtagh by Christopher Paolini
adventurous
dark
mysterious
slow-paced
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
2.5
If anyone has known me for long, they would know one of my first (and still favourite) series in fantasy is The Inheritance Cycle by Christopher Paolini. To say I've been looking forward to another book in this world is an understatement, though due to his less than stellar interludes such as The Fork the Witch and the Worm I was a bit cautious on having my hopes too high.
While this book wasn't terrible, it definitely wasn't the book we were all waiting for. This book takes place a year after the final battle in the final book of the series and (of course) follows the lesser seen duo of the series, Thorn and Murtagh. I really did enjoy finally seen the world from their PoV. Seeing just how the trials and tribulations of the original series had long lasting and immense effects upon these characters make them all the more important. We have a lot of small flashbacks to the horrors experienced by both Thorn and Murtagh which give better understanding and nuance to why these characters are the way they are. Seeing the bond between Thorn and Murtagh on a micro scale makes these characters all the easier to root for as individuals, and not just for their tortured past.
Sooo, the story is really where this book fails for me. I see a lot of readers rating the first half as a bit too DnD side-quest-y and finding the second half a lot more compelling but I had the opposite opinion. I loved seeing Murtagh and Thorn navigating their way towards a clear goal with a clear moral core was fantastically done. I liked seeing Murtagh contrasted against the average joe, seeing both how far he's come from being a normal human, but still so far he is away from where Eragon ended up at the end of the previous series.
-SPOILERS FROM HERE ON-
The second half seems to do away with this and introduce a whole new world-ending threat we're never seen, heard, or predicted would exist. Having this 'big bad' be introduced in such a badly paced and not as the start of a new series felt like a poor decision, in my opinion. Not only that, but the big bad retcons a lot of the previous threats seen in this world and I did NOT like that. The fact Murtagh and Thorn not only go to this potentially dangerous village with minimal warning to their friends, they also decide to just hang out there for days on end with little explanation or reason to while being aware of the fact it's a stupid and dangerous decision. Having both these characters once again go through the same trauma of capture, torture, and being broken as we get hints of throughout the book just felt gross and unearned. For a series I grew up loving for it's hopeful narrative interwoven between magic and whimsy, this book barely felt a part of that series. I understand people take this as a more 'adult' approach to Paolini's writing but it reads as badly paced and poorly thought out... I did like the first half, though. :')
While this book wasn't terrible, it definitely wasn't the book we were all waiting for. This book takes place a year after the final battle in the final book of the series and (of course) follows the lesser seen duo of the series, Thorn and Murtagh. I really did enjoy finally seen the world from their PoV. Seeing just how the trials and tribulations of the original series had long lasting and immense effects upon these characters make them all the more important. We have a lot of small flashbacks to the horrors experienced by both Thorn and Murtagh which give better understanding and nuance to why these characters are the way they are. Seeing the bond between Thorn and Murtagh on a micro scale makes these characters all the easier to root for as individuals, and not just for their tortured past.
Sooo, the story is really where this book fails for me. I see a lot of readers rating the first half as a bit too DnD side-quest-y and finding the second half a lot more compelling but I had the opposite opinion. I loved seeing Murtagh and Thorn navigating their way towards a clear goal with a clear moral core was fantastically done. I liked seeing Murtagh contrasted against the average joe, seeing both how far he's come from being a normal human, but still so far he is away from where Eragon ended up at the end of the previous series.
-SPOILERS FROM HERE ON-
The second half seems to do away with this and introduce a whole new world-ending threat we're never seen, heard, or predicted would exist. Having this 'big bad' be introduced in such a badly paced and not as the start of a new series felt like a poor decision, in my opinion. Not only that, but the big bad retcons a lot of the previous threats seen in this world and I did NOT like that. The fact Murtagh and Thorn not only go to this potentially dangerous village with minimal warning to their friends, they also decide to just hang out there for days on end with little explanation or reason to while being aware of the fact it's a stupid and dangerous decision. Having both these characters once again go through the same trauma of capture, torture, and being broken as we get hints of throughout the book just felt gross and unearned. For a series I grew up loving for it's hopeful narrative interwoven between magic and whimsy, this book barely felt a part of that series. I understand people take this as a more 'adult' approach to Paolini's writing but it reads as badly paced and poorly thought out... I did like the first half, though. :')
Content Warnings
Graphic: Mental illness, Slavery, Torture