rjleamon11 's review for:

The Amulet of Samarkand by Jonathan Stroud
3.0

Listened to this ya fantasy on Dawn's recommendation, and I did enjoy it: the reader was excellent, and the story is a gleeful, explanation-free "alternate reality" in which magicians rule London and Prague (but not the rest of the world?) while a non-magical Resistance is fighting against them, but there are cars and telephones. It felt a bit like Patrick Rothfuss's books where you just have to dive in and take what you're given.

However, Stroud's characters are mostly unlikable, it's yet another male-centered fantasy world, and by the end the unpredictability began to feel like a deliberate set-up to make me read the other two novels to figure it all out. Well, I don't think I like the people well enough to go through two more books, though I might skim the next one to figure out the grand idea.

And I *don't* feel like we've seen the end of Mrs. Underwood!