A review by theverbalthing
The Black Circle by Patrick Carman

3.0

This book had a lot more humor than the previous ones in the series. I thought it worked well with the overall situation and it was interesting to see Amy and Dan completely on their own, especially after being so closely tied to Nellie in the fourth book. Still wondering about the Madrigals, but very pleased with how the story is developing so far. For a series written by so many different authors, the consistency and character growth are remarkable to behold.