libkatem's profile picture

libkatem 's review for:

Hush: An Irish Princess' Tale by Donna Jo Napoli
3.0

The back story of a girl from a Norse fairytale that I've never heard before. It was good! I like Napoli's imagery in this work. Quite lovely.

Although it's portrayed as a strength, it worries me that Mel was willing to give up her voice so very quickly. As discussed by many feminist philosophers, a woman's voice is often her only weapon, and when it's taken away... bad things happen. However, given the circumstances, it completely fits the character of Mel to refuse to speak. I don't know.

It made me think, and that's always a good thing about a book.