You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.

catalogthis's profile picture

catalogthis 's review for:


I have never been so happy to discover a scheduling conflict.

This was a book club selection, and I realized today that I can't make it to this book club meeting. And while I did make it through the first 80 or so pages, I was dreading the discussion... I couldn't think of anything nice to say.

I won't give this a star rating (it seems unfair to rate something that I didn't finish) but I could tell right off the bat that this fell on the wrong side of my "show vs. tell" meter. The characters were caricatures, and the writing was cliche-ridden. Examples: The abusive husband who "smiled a mirthless smile" and a librarian "whose braided bun and eyeglass rims were the color of a steel filing cabinet" and a mixed-race baby whose skin was the color of... you can guess this one... yup. Coffee with cream.

Add to that a series of events that read less like life and more like scenes from something on Lifetime: Television for Women, and you've got yourself a recipe for something that I'm just not going to like.