A review by tapestryofwords
Saving Francesca by Melina Marchetta

4.0

This review was for my blog event Psychtember, so it's formatted a little differently than usual, to reflect the mental health theme. I've structured things as though the book is the patient and I'm giving them an assessment. Each axis is an aspect of the book that I'll give my thoughts on (characters, plot, etc.), and the validity score refers to how psychologically accurate I think the book is, with the final diagnosis being my shooting star rating. The rating still reflects my overall view of the book, using my standard rating system.

Patient: Saving Francesca by Melina Marchetta

Assessment:

Axis 1. Characters

Melina Marchetta nails the voice in this novel. Frankie is dryly witty, making all these observations about school life that reminded me, in a way, of Jane Austen's subtly deprecating social commentary (though obviously the style and tone are quite different). It's enjoyable to see Frankie grow through the course of the novel, learning to allow herself to just be herself. I like how she begins to appreciate all the little things in life that cheer her up.

Thomas Mackee was an oddly endearing character. He comes across as a jerk, especially at the beginning, but at the same time you want to believe he's a good guy. Occasionally he demonstrates flashes of sensitivity that keep you hoping. I wasn't as big a fan of Will, but I have to admit he does develop as a person. He behaves pretty badly towards Frankie at the start (and also,

Spoiler

I didn't like the fact that he cheated on his girlfriend

), but eventually he realizes that he shouldn't be so structured and that he needs to shake up his life.

I had a difficult time getting a handle on the relationship between Frankie and her mom. My first impression was that there was a lot of tension going on there, and resentment from Frankie — she calls her mom "Mia" and claims she's always trying to run Frankie's life. But then when it becomes apparent her mom is clinically depressed, Frankie reacts differently than I might have expected and it seems the two of them are closer than I'd thought. I felt like I was missing a whole dimension of their relationship, and I ended up feeling disconnected from Frankie's emotions over her mother's depression for a good part of the story.

It was sweet to see Frankie's strong connection with her younger brother; there aren't enough sibling relationships like that in YA. I also loved the friendships that Frankie forges throughout the novel. The bonding that happens between four such different individuals (Frankie, Siobhan, Justine and Tara) is a treat to watch as it unfolds. Most of the characters are multi-dimensional, defying stereotype. The one I wish I could have gotten to know better was Justine, as I feel like we don't really get to see much beyond the surface of her.

Axis 2. Premise/plot

There isn't one overarching cohesive plot. The mom's depression serves as the catalyst for the story, and also keeps the momentum going to some degree, although the pacing is quite slow. It's very much a character-driven book, with Frankie discovering how to become the person she once was (and lost) and quit pretending to be someone she isn't.

Axis 3. Writing Style

I really liked the subtle humour in this novel; the tone is fresh and distinctive. Indeed, I found myself laughing out loud on several occasions as I read. The Italian influence in the book also really gave it character; the inter-generational family provided a lively cast, and the occasional Italian words made it feel more authentic.

The dialogue is real and clever, flavourful and unique. The guys sound like teenage guys you might know in your own life: frequently obnoxious, and occasionally sweet in their own way.

We see Frankie's life through snippets, rather than one continuous narrative. I didn't mind this for the most part, as it seemed to fit Frankie's way of viewing the world. However, I did sometimes feel like I got told things when I wanted to see them instead. This was particularly the case for the mother's depression, its effect on the family, and Frankie's interactions with her mother. We get to be privy to so many interactions with Frankie's friends and acquaintances from school, but I wanted to see more of the family life. Later on, after her mother has been depressed for a while, the impact does become more apparent, particularly in how Frankie's dad changes.

Axis 4. Psychological Accuracy

We don't get to see that much of her mother Mia's symptoms, but several of the ones we do see are indicative of a major depressive episode. She's lost her appetite, has no energy — to the point where she can't get out of bed — and just generally seems to have acquired a different personality overnight. This behaviour continues for months, so she definitely meets the 2-week criterion for a major depressive episode.

There were a couple of Mia's symptoms I was less sure about. One was that she often vomits in the morning, which as far as I'm aware is not a typical symptom of depression. The other is that she seems to have enough energy to converse with Jimmy, but not so much with her own daughter. I can see that she would likely try harder to appear "normal" around a stranger, but it seems convenient that she is always up for a chat with him. Depression usually isn't quite that flexible, from what I understand. But I did enjoy seeing how Jimmy helps her mom by being someone she can talk to who isn't a member of her family, someone who doesn't inherently make her feel guilty about her depression and the toll it's taking on her loved ones.

I have to admit, it frustrated me that Mia is never taken to a mental health professional. As my education in psychology placed a strong emphasis on evidence-based treatment, I dearly wanted to sit down and have a long chat with Frankie's dad about anti-depressants. His dismissive attitude, while understandable to a certain extent, would not be helpful in a discussion about treatment options. And medication aside, psychotherapy has also been shown effective in treating many cases of depression.

Spoiler

While I do think it was very healthy for Mia to finally talk about the miscarriage, and could certainly signify a turning point, I thought her recovery was a bit quick for reality. And personally, I would have recommended she seek professional help. After all, even though she is able to pull herself out of this episode independently, there is still the possibility she may have a tendency to depression and experience it again in the future.

I appreciated that the stigma of having a family member with a mental health problem is addressed. Frankie calls up some of her mom's friends/acquaintances at one point, telling them that Mia's depressed, and they all interpret it in different ways — but all incorrectly. I'd say there's greater awareness of depression than there used to be, and it's more openly acknowledged, but I think the casual use of the word can cause confusion when the clinical definition is actually intended. I was surprised that Frankie and her family took so long to arrive at the conclusion that her mom is depressed, given that it's quite common these days. Generally speaking, the stigma is not as bad as it once was, and certainly not as negative as the attitudes towards some other mental disorders (such as schizophrenia or even bipolar disorder).

That said, of course, it depends a lot on the individual and the community, and I can certainly understand Frankie's reluctance to admit her mother's depression to others, and even to herself at first.

Frankie also exhibits some symptoms of depression — she's often tired and sad — but it's never stated that she herself is clinically depressed. I'd venture that perhaps what she has is dysthymia — its symptoms are not as extreme as major depression, but it involves a chronically low mood. Francesca herself at one point realizes that her lack of happiness has been going on for a while now, since before her mom's problems started.

Validity Score: How psychologically accurate was Saving Francesca?



Axis 5. Miscellaneous

I always like it when a beginning and end mirror each other, and it was no exception with Saving Francesca. It makes sense that since it started with her mother, it should end the same way.

Diagnosis: 4 shooting stars. Given my fondness for Thomas Mackee, I'm definitely looking forward to reading his story in The Piper's Son!

For more information on depression, go here.

For the full original version of this review, see my blog, A Tapestry of Words.