This book was interesting, but I think it was trying to do too much. It wanted to be an informative historical essay, a call to action, and a mystery all at once, but it couldn't be all of that. So it ended up feeling disjointed to me. I thought if the twist had come earlier, or if the story had committed more to a genre, it would have worked more effectively. Instead, we're tossed into a bunch of point of views and never really get a sense of the characters as a whole. The last 75% of this book is where it shines, but then it ends very abruptly, and the payoff doesn't really come. Which was a bummer because the premise and the story were definitely compelling.
My first foray into Maya Angelou's writing--and I get it!! This was not only a super interesting autobiography, but Angelou has such a unique and gorgeous writing style. This book nearly read like fiction the way I was whizzing through it, dying to know what would happen next. Also the only autobiography I've ever read that felt like it ended on a cliffhanger? I need to read the rest of her autobiographies because wow. It's always such a joy to witness such a prolific writer for the first time and truly understand why they're one of the greats; this was my experience with this book.
This was such a sweet read! I loved how developed the characters were and this premise is just too good. The author also had a funny tone to her writing that wasn't trying too hard and worked perfectly. The book was probably a bit long and felt like it was two parts, but I didn't even mind because I loved hanging out with the characters. It was such a cool idea overall and was executed super well.
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.0
I love a book that is also a time capsule. Sometimes it really is brutal to read about growing up a girl, which is just so sad. But this book was bittersweet in that way that really encapsulates girlhood, I think.
I fear I'm an Ali Hazelwood stan. I contemplated not giving this 5 stars, but the disappointment I felt after finishing it knowing I wouldn't get to spend more time with these characters and never read it for the first time again, made me feel like it was deserving of all those 5 stars. This could change, largely because as much as I loved Lukas as the protector in this, I wish we'd gotten to see more moments where he was struggling like Scarlett was. Just because I think the relationship would have been slightly more dynamic if she had to take care of him a little more onscreen. I loved this book because the characters were so well-crafted. I also love Ali's ability to change her writing/narration style across books for her characters. Scarlett was so specific, and I loved her and loved being in her head. I am sad this is over, but I am reassured by the fact that Madame Hazelwood will continue writing books and that I can always pick this up and reread it :)
This was super interesting! It was a little hard to get through sometimes just because the content is so dense--but that's on the music industry making up random rules in order for it to take advantage of artists. This probably would've stuck better in my brain if I read it instead of listening to it on audio, but it was still a very interesting book. It essentially explains why everything sucks even though you already know it does. Useful to know the why!
Read this book a bit faster than was wise because OOF it packed a punch. I really enjoy how these books are tackling such heavy "grown up" themes throughout them. This one was a bit slow to start and then picked up in the second half or so.
I liked this but there was a lot of almost-conflict and not as much full on conflict as I may have liked. I'm really into this love triangle thing though, sorry not sorry! Looking forward to Breanna leveling up in the next book. I think this was a fun read but it was clearly setting the stage for a lot of the future books. And I'll allow it because I anticipate these next books being realll good.
Ooh this was EVERYTHING I was hoping it would be!! The wait was well worth it for these characters. This book almost had a different tone than Tessa's others in general and in the series, and I think that's because the relationship was that much more intense and that was reflected in her writing. There were certainly some flaws and times I had to suspend my disbelief--and I simply did not care! This was just a fun read. The tension was insane. I think it's safe to say this is now my favorite book in this series.