horrifying, grotesque, and the type of book i cancelled plans and stayed up way too late to read. the imagery in this book was so vivid i could almost imagine it as a movie scene playing out.
UGH, this was the classic example of a book with an incredible premise, but poor execution. :(
Much of the lives of Berdis Baldwin, Louise Little, and Alberta King have been lost to time and erasure. In history books and our recounting of their sons' lives and legacies, these three women have often been left out or only included as mere footnotes. I was hoping this book would introduce us to these women, the lives they led, and the passions they had.
Unfortunately, it didn't do much of anything it set out to do. THE THREE MOTHERS recounted the histories of MLK, Malcolm X, and James Baldwin and included a section about how their mothers supported them and loved them. Or, it speculated about the beliefs the three mothers may have had, but no citation of actual primary sources.
If you have NO background or information on Black history (ie: great migration, Jim Crow laws, garveyism), this is a great book for you. It is a digestible introduction to many histories and ideas.
However, if you want more information about these women, I recommend reading the works of these three men where they reference and discuss their mothers. Autobiography of Malcolm X, Go Tell It on The Mountain, and this article on Alberta King are great places to start.
I absolutely ATE this up! I can't remember the last time I read a book in 24 hours, and I finally did with WHISPER DOWN THE LANE.
Side Note: Anyone in reviews saying "Psssh NO one in the 80s was believing DnD was from the devil or cabbage patch kids were demonic" clearly never interacted with evangelical christians, because I even heard those sentiments into the early 2000s
a beautiful memoir about cats, the way we care for one another, relationships, and the human condition. i am so glad my most anticipated book of 2025 lived up to my own hype.
Grotesque and INCREDIBLE! I love strange fiction that stretches the re-evaluates the sociology of motherhood. The messaging does slap you in the face a bit towards the end, but overall I had such a fun time with NIGHTBITCH.
TW for death of animals specifically rabbits, raccoon, and one house cat (in great detail)