WHAT THIS BOOK IS: a slow-burning revenge story in space
WHAT THIS BOOK HAS: loyalty, animal AI, a literally calculating protagonist who has an unironic love for dramas, animal AI, crises of pastry, 2 people sharing a body
This was great! The visual detail and worldbuilding are amazing; I kept getting distracted imagining how the signifiers change forms. At some point I had to stop reading just to take in the description of a sinister candle (whose existence gave us a deeper sense of the history and context of the current regime).
The editing is very *chef's kiss*. The entire novel is a product of conscious, careful choice, no scene wasted.
I liked this a lot more than Uprooted, although I still have the SOFTEST spot for the Agnieszka/Kasia relationship in Uprooted.
Spinning Silver was a very slow but rewarding read for me. I loved having 3 heroines who each had her own problems and priorities that were sometimes at odds with each other's. I still think the plot could have been streamlined; the other POVs feel extraneous in the end (*cough* Stepon), and the narrative could have benefited from plumping up the heroines' POVs more. The canon romance felt rushed and overdone. I wish it had been left platonic, but Miryem's story and the Jewish fantasy that came with it were strong enough that it didn't bother me too much. I love it and her magic SO much, every drop of it was earned and paid for.
This is an effective outsider's POV in that I got hysterically emotional whenever Cheris/Jedao so much as breathed. The POV is so opaque that I was fully attuned to every twitch of their fingers, hungrily hoarding every scrap of observation about them. Cheris/Jedao's entire existence is still very much an open wound to me, even though it's been a year since I read Ninefox Gambit. If I loved Cheris in the first book, I loved her 100 times more here, and I'm still just super emotional about her and Jedao's storyline, especially as Cheris continues to make the hard choices and attempt the impossible.
Overall Raven Stratagem feels very much like a transitional book. It introduced a host of new characters with their own sets of conflicts and decision-making, and I'm looking forward to getting to the end of the trilogy. I'm a huuuuuge fan of themes of loyalty, so watching the Kels be confronted with the meaning of it was 10/10.
This book also made me seriously contemplate growing my own spring onions, I was SO jealous of Mikodez. :(((((
I don't always agree with her, but these are all excellent and well-structured essays that have shaped some of my conversations. It's just nice to read longform pieces about pop culture that aren't about specific shows/books. Worth owning in hard copy (I only borrowed my friend's copy).
Never got to write about my thoughts about it, but I loved this novella, it's so captivating. I like it so much better than the first, but more than that, I think it enhances the first since it just works so well as a series. I hope there's more!
I found this nice but mostly just okay. I'm not sure if the novella length/structure worked for or against the story. The cover's really pretty though.
...I didn't read the novel extras, only the 37 main novel chapters, does that count as finishing the book???? Not sure if I want to, but maybe I should.....
Thoughts: - characters are 30 y/o, and act like it! - loved the FL, she’s v mature, self-sufficient, and has her life together. - i loved everything up to the e-sports tournament, but kinda lost interest after—i didn’t really care much about the ML’s POV or the get-together. - there were great scenes about being an adult and not having your life together enough for emergencies & family situations, it really touched a nerve - i didn’t think the ML had enough personality for me to care about his character growth. but i liked how he was always so supportive & happy of the FL. - overall, a cute and short romance