Scan barcode
hobbithopeful's reviews
219 reviews
Cursed Boys and Broken Hearts by Adam Sass
emotional
funny
hopeful
inspiring
reflective
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.5
Honest, funny, and all too close to home, Adam Sass stuns yet again in a thorny romance about curses, love, and the raw emotion of dealing with a brain that would rather be a beast than a bunny.
Grant would rather stay hidden in his depression pit, yet ends up instead at the suggestion of his family, helping to facelift and bring back from despair his aunt's vineyard and B&B. Add in one hot gardener who is also his ex best friend, and who broke his heart and things get...complicated. And very, very, messy. Sass has such a unique writing style and I've yet to find another author who so perfectly captures complex and messy characters who aren't perfect. Characters who are terribly, honestly human, and struggling to figure themselves out. When I think of writers who capture (my at least), queer experience, Sass is always at the forefront of my mind.
Part of the reason I had trouble with Grant as a character at times, is because it is never easy reading a book that is basically holding a mirror to yourself and all of your (quite frankly unresolved) issues. I myself struggle will pulling frequent "Grant moments", retreating from the world for weeks or months, only emerging like a shade to sometimes eat, and haunt my apartment like a wraith of some terribly dramatic play or period drama.
A quote that very succinctly captures who Grant is at a character, in all his glory and mental health issues:
"I emerged from a three-day depression hole less than an hour ago, and I'm still gonna be the cutest one in the room. Who else but me? I can do it all! Lowest lows, highest highs."
There were moments when reading, when I turned and looked at a non existent camera b, as if to say, 'I feel attacked right now', because so many moments it felt more as if Grant's growth and troubles was parallel to my stupid brain and everything I struggle with. Even at times where I wanted to bemoan how messy he was being, or get annoyed at his pettiness or jealousy, I had to take a step back and think, 'no but for real, I would/have done the same thing.'
I really enjoyed the depictions of food and the messy family relationships. I did grow quite hungry reading this, which is always a sign that that the prose and imagery had thoroughly reached my appetite. Speaking of hungry, the boys in this book were Thirsty, with a capital T. The chemistry between Grant and Ben was written so well, it didn't feel forced or out of nowhere. Their banter and flirting was done so well, reading two characters fight against their own yearning and feelings is always such a treat when they finally come together.
One more quick thing I loved, the mention of therapy, medication, and the very real reality of dealing with mental health and the never ending journey that is. Spot on in a way that was so raw and honest, yet again hitting me in my chest because it so very much resembled my own.
"She's such a good friend- no matter how long we go without talking, she's there for me when I come back." This is another sentence that felt like it was plucked straight from my life, and perfectly encompasses anyone who has those who stick by you even when you tend to ghost everyone at frequent occurrences.
I think it could be argued that there were moments when Sass took out a proverbial soap box, to educate the reader as much as characters in the story, such as when talking about how to give space to a queer child. Though I won't lie, it was healing, cathartic and realistic in how the family interacted. Especially how Grant was able to pinpoint that his nephew would be having a when not if coming out.
At the same time, there are a times sentences like this, where words like 'my thorniest thorn', and 'childhood ashes like phoenixes,' were likely intended to be taken seriously but it was difficult too.
He saw my weirdest, most serial-killer behavior- my thorniest thorn-and it only made him want to help me more....Adult Ben and Adult Grant have emerged from our childhood ashes like phoenixes." These moments and other moments of choice writing broke me out of my reading at times to just blink, pulled out of the immersive story I had been so far loving.
I did find the ending one of the weakest parts of the book, apart from how perfectly everything lined up and how the main characters were perfectly fine with wearing someone else's robes and staying in a stranger's apartment, it lacked what the rest of the story had in terms of strong writing and felt a bit plot convenient. (On the other hand I am torn because I am always delighted to read a queer story where there is a happy ending and no one is killed off or other angsty things happen. (Looking at you, nearly every show ever with queer characters!) If the last chunk had stayed as strong and consistent as the rest of the book, this would have easily been a five star read for me.
I do recommend this book, especially perfect for fans of Adam Sass's writing style, this story is sweet and full bodied, worth every page.
Thank you to Penguin for this ARC, NOTE any quotes are subject to change since this is an ARC that I read and reviewed
Grant would rather stay hidden in his depression pit, yet ends up instead at the suggestion of his family, helping to facelift and bring back from despair his aunt's vineyard and B&B. Add in one hot gardener who is also his ex best friend, and who broke his heart and things get...complicated. And very, very, messy. Sass has such a unique writing style and I've yet to find another author who so perfectly captures complex and messy characters who aren't perfect. Characters who are terribly, honestly human, and struggling to figure themselves out. When I think of writers who capture (my at least), queer experience, Sass is always at the forefront of my mind.
Part of the reason I had trouble with Grant as a character at times, is because it is never easy reading a book that is basically holding a mirror to yourself and all of your (quite frankly unresolved) issues. I myself struggle will pulling frequent "Grant moments", retreating from the world for weeks or months, only emerging like a shade to sometimes eat, and haunt my apartment like a wraith of some terribly dramatic play or period drama.
A quote that very succinctly captures who Grant is at a character, in all his glory and mental health issues:
"I emerged from a three-day depression hole less than an hour ago, and I'm still gonna be the cutest one in the room. Who else but me? I can do it all! Lowest lows, highest highs."
There were moments when reading, when I turned and looked at a non existent camera b, as if to say, 'I feel attacked right now', because so many moments it felt more as if Grant's growth and troubles was parallel to my stupid brain and everything I struggle with. Even at times where I wanted to bemoan how messy he was being, or get annoyed at his pettiness or jealousy, I had to take a step back and think, 'no but for real, I would/have done the same thing.'
I really enjoyed the depictions of food and the messy family relationships. I did grow quite hungry reading this, which is always a sign that that the prose and imagery had thoroughly reached my appetite. Speaking of hungry, the boys in this book were Thirsty, with a capital T. The chemistry between Grant and Ben was written so well, it didn't feel forced or out of nowhere. Their banter and flirting was done so well, reading two characters fight against their own yearning and feelings is always such a treat when they finally come together.
One more quick thing I loved, the mention of therapy, medication, and the very real reality of dealing with mental health and the never ending journey that is. Spot on in a way that was so raw and honest, yet again hitting me in my chest because it so very much resembled my own.
"She's such a good friend- no matter how long we go without talking, she's there for me when I come back." This is another sentence that felt like it was plucked straight from my life, and perfectly encompasses anyone who has those who stick by you even when you tend to ghost everyone at frequent occurrences.
I think it could be argued that there were moments when Sass took out a proverbial soap box, to educate the reader as much as characters in the story, such as when talking about how to give space to a queer child. Though I won't lie, it was healing, cathartic and realistic in how the family interacted. Especially how Grant was able to pinpoint that his nephew would be having a when not if coming out.
At the same time, there are a times sentences like this, where words like 'my thorniest thorn', and 'childhood ashes like phoenixes,' were likely intended to be taken seriously but it was difficult too.
He saw my weirdest, most serial-killer behavior- my thorniest thorn-and it only made him want to help me more....Adult Ben and Adult Grant have emerged from our childhood ashes like phoenixes." These moments and other moments of choice writing broke me out of my reading at times to just blink, pulled out of the immersive story I had been so far loving.
I did find the ending one of the weakest parts of the book, apart from how perfectly everything lined up and how the main characters were perfectly fine with wearing someone else's robes and staying in a stranger's apartment, it lacked what the rest of the story had in terms of strong writing and felt a bit plot convenient. (On the other hand I am torn because I am always delighted to read a queer story where there is a happy ending and no one is killed off or other angsty things happen. (Looking at you, nearly every show ever with queer characters!) If the last chunk had stayed as strong and consistent as the rest of the book, this would have easily been a five star read for me.
I do recommend this book, especially perfect for fans of Adam Sass's writing style, this story is sweet and full bodied, worth every page.
Thank you to Penguin for this ARC, NOTE any quotes are subject to change since this is an ARC that I read and reviewed
Content Warnings
Graphic: Mental illness, Homophobia, and Alcohol
Minor: Cancer, Sexual content, Misogyny, and Death
That Time I Got Drunk and Saved a Demon by Kimberly Lemming
funny
lighthearted
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.5
I've never laughed so hard reading such a steamy romance, I couldn't stop smiling throughout the whole story. As irreverent as it is sweet, who knew the adventure that would come from getting drunk and saving a demon? Cin as a character is laugh out loud relatable and funny, she truly wants nothing more then to just mind her business and not be caught up in any adventures or main character-ing. Of course that is not how the story goes!
Fallon is peak male romance lead, masculine and protective, and more then willing to rip a man's arm clean off just as easily as he is able to kiss Cin senseless. (And he does both of those tasks quite frequently!) It is difficult not to fall in love with Lemming's writing, the amount of fun she seemed to have had in these pages makes reading it such a treat and delight. There is quite a bit of slang and jargon that will surely be outdated in a few years time, but for now it hits in that sweet spot of sounding just like how any other unwilling heroine might.
There are several scenes that get quite spicy, and they are written very well. VERY. WELL. I am not saying I am willing to be whisked away on a quest and gain a demon mate in the process, but I'm not NOT saying that. (Please any technologically aware demons, hit me up if you're reading this.)
A highlight of reading is all of the food parts, Cin loves to eat and all the food descriptors and her passion for her next meal also made my stomach growl, and kept the story light. A memorable scene is when Cin found out she had declared herself the cheese queen. I had to pause and just laugh to myself because it felt so silly, yet so right for this story. "Because I fully remember you tasking several orcs to bring you cheese. Then you sat in the captain;'s chair and the words 'I am the cheese queen' definitely came out of your mouth."
I do wish there were parts that weren't so rushed, the beginning was nice, but it quickly ramped up to the point the ending felt quite a bit rushed. I did enjoy it, even if Cin fell in love over the span of such a short time period, I can't say I wouldn't do the same when faced with such a sexy dragon.
It is a testament to Lemming's writing that even with how quickly the plot flies by in this short read, it sticks in your mind and leaves you satiated. But that is to say the pacing is far different in the beginning then it is in the end. When I realized there was only a few chapters left I was wondering just how the tasks the hero's were trying to accomplish was going to get done, with all the travel that been mentioned. In a way a part of it did feel a tinge unsatisfying, but it was so much fun I didn't truly mind.
This is my first book of Kimberly Lemming's, I NEED to read the rest of the series now. If you're looking for a funny and steamy short read, this is perfect for you, highly recommend!
Fallon is peak male romance lead, masculine and protective, and more then willing to rip a man's arm clean off just as easily as he is able to kiss Cin senseless. (And he does both of those tasks quite frequently!) It is difficult not to fall in love with Lemming's writing, the amount of fun she seemed to have had in these pages makes reading it such a treat and delight. There is quite a bit of slang and jargon that will surely be outdated in a few years time, but for now it hits in that sweet spot of sounding just like how any other unwilling heroine might.
There are several scenes that get quite spicy, and they are written very well. VERY. WELL. I am not saying I am willing to be whisked away on a quest and gain a demon mate in the process, but I'm not NOT saying that. (Please any technologically aware demons, hit me up if you're reading this.)
A highlight of reading is all of the food parts, Cin loves to eat and all the food descriptors and her passion for her next meal also made my stomach growl, and kept the story light. A memorable scene is when Cin found out she had declared herself the cheese queen. I had to pause and just laugh to myself because it felt so silly, yet so right for this story. "Because I fully remember you tasking several orcs to bring you cheese. Then you sat in the captain;'s chair and the words 'I am the cheese queen' definitely came out of your mouth."
I do wish there were parts that weren't so rushed, the beginning was nice, but it quickly ramped up to the point the ending felt quite a bit rushed. I did enjoy it, even if Cin fell in love over the span of such a short time period, I can't say I wouldn't do the same when faced with such a sexy dragon.
It is a testament to Lemming's writing that even with how quickly the plot flies by in this short read, it sticks in your mind and leaves you satiated. But that is to say the pacing is far different in the beginning then it is in the end. When I realized there was only a few chapters left I was wondering just how the tasks the hero's were trying to accomplish was going to get done, with all the travel that been mentioned. In a way a part of it did feel a tinge unsatisfying, but it was so much fun I didn't truly mind.
This is my first book of Kimberly Lemming's, I NEED to read the rest of the series now. If you're looking for a funny and steamy short read, this is perfect for you, highly recommend!
Content Warnings
Graphic: Murder, Sexual content, Violence, Blood, and Vomit
Moderate: Slavery
Minor: Sexual harassment
They Ain't Proper by M.B. Guel
adventurous
lighthearted
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
2.0
An extremely disappointing read that would have benefited from characters that didn't need a side one to constantly fix their relationship and keep them together, as well as more stringent editing in the second half of the story.
The premise is a strong one, the wild west, Clementine has sold herself as a wife to get out of her family debt. Lou just wants to be left alone, but an accidental mix up leads to Clementine being delivered to Lou instead of the surly husband she was meant for.
Listen, dear reader. I was so pumped, ecstatic even, to read a non-binary romance. It is rare to get an AFAB romance, even rarer for it to be an adult one. (Which is why I bought this to take on vacation!) It started off fairly well, and I liked how it went, but the plot quickly became muddled in the second half, and it became clear without the side character Juanita, that Lou and Clementine wouldn't even be together in the first place. (The amount of fights and miscommunication and storming off felt out of place, and unnecessary.) Juanita had to keep intervening, and involving herself in the relationship to make them talk to each other, and also serve as a major plot device.
If you took Juanita out of the story, there would be no relationship between Clementine and Lou, and quite frankly Lou would probably be dead.
But on to the bigger fish I had an issue with.
The second half of the book. I don't even know where to begin with it.
The story could have, and honestly should have ended after Lou was saved from being hung. Instead we have people coming from the past, with no real purpose or plot point other than to disrupt the relationship and cause unnecessary fighting and distancing. I had absolutely checked out by this point and was struggling to get through. It was quite frankly, a slog. I briefly considered DNF'ing, but because I paid money, I was determined to finish in the hopes it might get better. I still see little to no point in having Inez pop up, as well as others. It was like the climax had already came and went, and so the story was just being dragged out for no reason. I don't understand how editing works, especially with smaller publishers, but this book NEEDED more editing.
By the end I found myself quite disliking several characters I had earlier loved, if only because of the way the plot went that nothing was making sense or felt necessary. I went from liking Clementine, to finding her immature and quite frankly more suited to a YA novel with her constant jumping to conclusions and jealousy. (It's giving toxic.)
Let me complain about one more thing. Breaking a horse does not take just a few days, or even a few weeks. Especially a grown and wild horse! This might be my horse training background from my past coming in, but that part of the book really broke me out of the reading and it just felt so unbelievable.
Oh, and lord only knows what is going on with the cover and the absolute interesting proportions, as well as the fact nothing about the composition makes sense. (Who has limbs going where, why is the horse shaped like that, what even is going on.) Somehow Clementine's arm is longer than Trigger's entire head and Lou's forearm is longer than Clementine's whole arm. Don't even get me started on the legs.)
Overall this book had me so excited, but ended up being a disappointing read, and a slog I almost didn't finish.
I rarely buy books before reading them, and this reminded me why, I do deeply regret having spent money on this book. I do NOT recommend this.
The premise is a strong one, the wild west, Clementine has sold herself as a wife to get out of her family debt. Lou just wants to be left alone, but an accidental mix up leads to Clementine being delivered to Lou instead of the surly husband she was meant for.
Listen, dear reader. I was so pumped, ecstatic even, to read a non-binary romance. It is rare to get an AFAB romance, even rarer for it to be an adult one. (Which is why I bought this to take on vacation!) It started off fairly well, and I liked how it went, but the plot quickly became muddled in the second half, and it became clear without the side character Juanita, that Lou and Clementine wouldn't even be together in the first place. (The amount of fights and miscommunication and storming off felt out of place, and unnecessary.) Juanita had to keep intervening, and involving herself in the relationship to make them talk to each other, and also serve as a major plot device.
If you took Juanita out of the story, there would be no relationship between Clementine and Lou, and quite frankly Lou would probably be dead.
But on to the bigger fish I had an issue with.
The second half of the book. I don't even know where to begin with it.
The story could have, and honestly should have ended after
By the end I found myself quite disliking several characters I had earlier loved, if only because of the way the plot went that nothing was making sense or felt necessary. I went from liking Clementine, to finding her immature and quite frankly more suited to a YA novel with her constant jumping to conclusions and jealousy. (It's giving toxic.)
Let me complain about one more thing. Breaking a horse does not take just a few days, or even a few weeks. Especially a grown and wild horse! This might be my horse training background from my past coming in, but that part of the book really broke me out of the reading and it just felt so unbelievable.
Oh, and lord only knows what is going on with the cover and the absolute interesting proportions, as well as the fact nothing about the composition makes sense. (Who has limbs going where, why is the horse shaped like that, what even is going on.) Somehow Clementine's arm is longer than Trigger's entire head and Lou's forearm is longer than Clementine's whole arm. Don't even get me started on the legs.)
Overall this book had me so excited, but ended up being a disappointing read, and a slog I almost didn't finish.
I rarely buy books before reading them, and this reminded me why, I do deeply regret having spent money on this book. I do NOT recommend this.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Violence, Injury/Injury detail, Homophobia, Transphobia, Sexual content, and Alcoholism
Minor: Death of parent, Murder, and Death
A Lady's Guide to Scandal by Sophie Irwin
funny
lighthearted
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
Funny, sweet, and even better then the first book, this regency romp delighted and impressed me with its humor and a shy main character you can't help but root for.
Eliza's twenty year older husband has finally kicked the bucket and surprisingly left her with quite a bit of income, and a freedom she has never had before. Leaving her to finally pursue her own wants, but a stipulation in the will as well as a man she nearly married put quite a damper on her new life.
Getting to see Eliza come out of her shell and grow into her own person through the course of the book made me so happy. She goes through so much character growth in finally finding out who she is, and then being her own person and not letting others order her around. The scene where she went to the paint shop and all but demanded her supplies was everything.
Irwin does rapier wit and sharp dialogue well, and Lord Melville's sassy and colorful personality make that shine. He was by far my favorite character, a foil to the rigid and stifling society. His interactions with Eliza were my favorite, and even as I worked to not get too attached to him for fear of what I thought might happen, I couldn't help it and he remained my favorite till the end.
High society is no friend to anyone different, or of a different race, and the inclusion and discussion of Melville and Caroline and how they were treated both crushed me, and it hit in that place that anyone familiar with casual racism will recognize. Speaking of Caroline, THANK YOU Irwin, for giving us QUEER characters in this book! Regency and yearning and sapphics go so well, and how it would have worked in that time period felt so accurate as well as sweet and keeping in line with the lighter storyline.
Let me extoll upon Irwin's virtues once more, I truly enjoy the level of detail and research that goes into her writing. I feel like I learn so much about the time period and the vivid descriptions of thej food, outfits, and architecture make me feel like I am right there enjoying the opera or the waters of Bath.
Because the book blurb and even the back cover doesn't name the male lead outright, I really thought that Eliza was going to end up with Somerset. Considering that is who is first introduced and who she pines for, I was prepared for that pairing to be the end game. Which had me so sad because I was honestly loving Melville and his flamboyant self so much. (Sassy man apocalypse, it is the era and I am a stan) Irwin surprised me and it soon became clear that Melville WAS the male lead, and not merely suffering from second lead syndrome. (A fatal disease to be fair) It isn't often that the BIPOC member of a love triangle actually gets the girl, I honestly really loved this bit so much. Plus let us be frank. Somerset was an ass. AN ASS.
I almost would have liked for a bit of exploration into Eliza's experience with the Earl in terms what she would have experienced being forced to bed someone she cared little for, and who had zero respect for her. I understand why Irwin didn't, such a tragic topic isn't well suited to a light hearted story such as this one, but I do think it was a disservice not to at least address it in passing. (Though it could be argued that Eliza's entire personality for most of the book and actions could also be attributed to such a thing, so my musings may be for naught!)
I admit after reading the first book in the series, A Lady's Guide to Fortune-Hunting, my hopes were fairly standard. I didn't really expect to be surprised or enthralled by this book. I just expected mild enjoyment at best, the kind you get from a fairly solid sandwich and chips. A nice 4 star read, solid, but nothing to rave about. Imagine my surprise when I not only liked this book but I loved it. The inclusion of queer characters, diverse characters, and just a longer story in general made this a far more enjoyable read. There was more substance, more heart, and I can easily say this felt like less of a sandwich and more of a delectable feast that I wished I could have kept eating when it ended.
Once the pair come together, we only get such a short time to enjoy their moment. I would have liked to have seen an epilogue at the very least. If the two characters had to go through so much to get together, why not let the reader enjoy it and bask in it for more than a scant chapter or two?
I highly enjoyed this, I definitely recommend this book, one of my favorite regency romps to date. I do hope Sophie Irwin writes more in this series, and in this same vein, I will definitely read them.
I was sent this to read and review, thank you to the publisher.
Eliza's twenty year older husband has finally kicked the bucket and surprisingly left her with quite a bit of income, and a freedom she has never had before. Leaving her to finally pursue her own wants, but a stipulation in the will as well as a man she nearly married put quite a damper on her new life.
Getting to see Eliza come out of her shell and grow into her own person through the course of the book made me so happy. She goes through so much character growth in finally finding out who she is, and then being her own person and not letting others order her around. The scene where she went to the paint shop and all but demanded her supplies was everything.
Irwin does rapier wit and sharp dialogue well, and Lord Melville's sassy and colorful personality make that shine. He was by far my favorite character, a foil to the rigid and stifling society. His interactions with Eliza were my favorite, and even as I worked to not get too attached to him for fear of what I thought might happen, I couldn't help it and he remained my favorite till the end.
High society is no friend to anyone different, or of a different race, and the inclusion and discussion of Melville and Caroline and how they were treated both crushed me, and it hit in that place that anyone familiar with casual racism will recognize. Speaking of Caroline, THANK YOU Irwin, for giving us QUEER characters in this book! Regency and yearning and sapphics go so well, and how it would have worked in that time period felt so accurate as well as sweet and keeping in line with the lighter storyline.
Let me extoll upon Irwin's virtues once more, I truly enjoy the level of detail and research that goes into her writing. I feel like I learn so much about the time period and the vivid descriptions of thej food, outfits, and architecture make me feel like I am right there enjoying the opera or the waters of Bath.
Because the book blurb and even the back cover doesn't name the male lead outright, I really thought that Eliza was going to end up with
I almost would have liked for a bit of exploration into Eliza's experience with the Earl in terms what she would have experienced being forced to bed someone she cared little for, and who had zero respect for her. I understand why Irwin didn't, such a tragic topic isn't well suited to a light hearted story such as this one, but I do think it was a disservice not to at least address it in passing. (Though it could be argued that Eliza's entire personality for most of the book and actions could also be attributed to such a thing, so my musings may be for naught!)
I admit after reading the first book in the series, A Lady's Guide to Fortune-Hunting, my hopes were fairly standard. I didn't really expect to be surprised or enthralled by this book. I just expected mild enjoyment at best, the kind you get from a fairly solid sandwich and chips. A nice 4 star read, solid, but nothing to rave about. Imagine my surprise when I not only liked this book but I loved it. The inclusion of queer characters, diverse characters, and just a longer story in general made this a far more enjoyable read. There was more substance, more heart, and I can easily say this felt like less of a sandwich and more of a delectable feast that I wished I could have kept eating when it ended.
Once the pair come together, we only get such a short time to enjoy their moment. I would have liked to have seen an epilogue at the very least. If the two characters had to go through so much to get together, why not let the reader enjoy it and bask in it for more than a scant chapter or two?
I highly enjoyed this, I definitely recommend this book, one of my favorite regency romps to date. I do hope Sophie Irwin writes more in this series, and in this same vein, I will definitely read them.
I was sent this to read and review, thank you to the publisher.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Misogyny
Moderate: Classism, Racism, and Homophobia
Minor: Death
A Lady's Guide to Fortune-Hunting by Sophie Irwin
funny
lighthearted
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.0
Longing glances and hilarious moments made this read a welcome palate cleanser in the heavier stories I tend to find myself drawn to. Much like a nice snack, short and nice, and it didn't leave me bloated.
A true regency romp, Kitty needs a fortune to save her family from destitution and she will go to means to secure a man and his fortune. Manipulations, feminine wiles, Kitty takes no prisoners. Much to the chagrin of Lord Radcliffe, who seems to be only the one see through her manipulations and obvious fortune hunting.
I very much adored the descriptions and the dialogue. Rich clothing, and stifled manners made it so that I felt I was swirling about the ballrooms with the story. It is very much in vein as season one of Bridgerton, so fans of that will definitely enjoy this book.
The chemistry between Kitty and Radcliffe brought a smile to my face whenever the pair was on page, true foils to each other, I most enjoyed when they were driving each other wild.
(The way Lord Radcliffe is absolutely flummoxed by her showing up and making demands so early in the morning made me chuckle) "It was as if all his energy had been sapped form him in the face of that notebook, and all he could do was watch with muted despair as his previously peaceful morning faded away." I did wish they had more time together, and less with Kitty entertaining suitors that we all know she isn't going to end up with anyways.
At times I did wish the story wasn't so rushed, there were several times I felt the story could benefit from more showing than telling. I wouldn't have minded for the book to have been a bit longer, and for their to be more heart in it. At times it felt like by the time the two main characters met and started having interactions the book was already half over, or focusing on other subjects or events that I would have been spent on the main pair, especially given the short length.
I am not quite sure if I should classify this as YA or adult romance. The writing is sharp and witty, and the lack of spicy scenes makes it suitable for young ages yet still enthralling enough for an older audience with the strong writing. For the peace of my mind I am putting it into both of my shelves and calling it a day.
I enjoyed reading this, it was short and sweet, a welcome treat in my day. I do recommend it, if just so you can get to the second book in the series which I absolutely ADORE.
I was sent this book to read and review, thank you to the publisher.
A true regency romp, Kitty needs a fortune to save her family from destitution and she will go to means to secure a man and his fortune. Manipulations, feminine wiles, Kitty takes no prisoners. Much to the chagrin of Lord Radcliffe, who seems to be only the one see through her manipulations and obvious fortune hunting.
I very much adored the descriptions and the dialogue. Rich clothing, and stifled manners made it so that I felt I was swirling about the ballrooms with the story. It is very much in vein as season one of Bridgerton, so fans of that will definitely enjoy this book.
The chemistry between Kitty and Radcliffe brought a smile to my face whenever the pair was on page, true foils to each other, I most enjoyed when they were driving each other wild.
(The way Lord Radcliffe is absolutely flummoxed by her showing up and making demands so early in the morning made me chuckle) "It was as if all his energy had been sapped form him in the face of that notebook, and all he could do was watch with muted despair as his previously peaceful morning faded away." I did wish they had more time together, and less with Kitty entertaining suitors that we all know she isn't going to end up with anyways.
At times I did wish the story wasn't so rushed, there were several times I felt the story could benefit from more showing than telling. I wouldn't have minded for the book to have been a bit longer, and for their to be more heart in it. At times it felt like by the time the two main characters met and started having interactions the book was already half over, or focusing on other subjects or events that I would have been spent on the main pair, especially given the short length.
I am not quite sure if I should classify this as YA or adult romance. The writing is sharp and witty, and the lack of spicy scenes makes it suitable for young ages yet still enthralling enough for an older audience with the strong writing. For the peace of my mind I am putting it into both of my shelves and calling it a day.
I enjoyed reading this, it was short and sweet, a welcome treat in my day. I do recommend it, if just so you can get to the second book in the series which I absolutely ADORE.
I was sent this book to read and review, thank you to the publisher.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Classism
Minor: Panic attacks/disorders and War
Their Vicious Games by Joelle Wellington
A non stop thrill that I loved every second of, it was so unexpectedly excellent, and every twist and turn surprised me. (Which is rare!)
What would you do to get a second chance to regain everything you lost all because of a rich white girl? Adina will go far to regain her chance of college and getting out of the town she lives in. But she soon discovers the competition she has managed to get invited to has high stakes. Deadly stakes. Not everything is as it seems, and the glamour and polish of the rich cover up something far more sinister afoot. Unlikely allies seem to want to help her, but who can she really trust? And who will she have to become to survive? There are moments in this story which truly made me sick to the stomach, I strongly advise anyone to check their trigger warnings before reading.The Simon Says game really got me. It shows just how twisted the whole thing is, and how little value the girls are actually viewed as.
At the beginning I had a few moments of hesitance, never one to enjoy moments ofcheating no matter the reason or motivations. But it immediately picked up from there and I soon found myself unable to stop reading.
I can't say which character this is without spoiling, but she ended up being my favorite. This is an example of how strong and well written the prose is, one of my favorite quotes: ...In the gaps between her teeth, she holds bitterness and rage, the kind that has built with resentment for years...She is the moon, tethered forever to a planet that she does not want anything to do with but can't exist without."
The threads of classism, racism, and misogyny all tied around exquisitely written prose delighted my eyes and enraptured my mind. The story truly just got stronger as the book went on, and the tense and thrilling moments had my heart racing as fast as Adina's. One of my favorite characters was
What I liked most about this book was how biting and honest it was. Casual racism is an every day reality for many people (me included!) and to see how it was depicted so nearly subtly in a way that if you weren't familiar with some of the microaggressions you might think it was just an uncomfortable situation or think nothing of it. (Of course I would hope the more overt and direct racism instances in the book would open any reader's eyes who would dare to think otherwise, or even heaven forbid think this book as something else.)
I need to take a moment to talk about the ending, because it wasn't what I expected, nor have come to expect from books in this vein and I was more than pleasantly surprised.I am so GODDAMN SICK of books that deal with these topics just forget about it and have the BIPOC lead get with the white man at the end. So I was beyond THRILLED, dare I say ecstatic, when that was not the case here. Adin showcased the brains she had all book and it was left open ended in if she would ever contact Graham again. (Though dear reader, if I must truly be honest, I wouldn't mind if they reconnected at some point many years later after much growth and healing and learning. Because that man is ignorant as hell and it isn't Adina's job to educate him)
One more side note I want to add, should Joelle Wellington ever endeavor to pen an adult novel with romance, I would be first in line. The romance moments in this book well, let's just say I would very much love for more.
This is my first book of Joelle Wellington's, and with this quality of writing and storytelling I know it won't be last. Highly recommend.
dark
emotional
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
5.0
A non stop thrill that I loved every second of, it was so unexpectedly excellent, and every twist and turn surprised me. (Which is rare!)
What would you do to get a second chance to regain everything you lost all because of a rich white girl? Adina will go far to regain her chance of college and getting out of the town she lives in. But she soon discovers the competition she has managed to get invited to has high stakes. Deadly stakes. Not everything is as it seems, and the glamour and polish of the rich cover up something far more sinister afoot. Unlikely allies seem to want to help her, but who can she really trust? And who will she have to become to survive? There are moments in this story which truly made me sick to the stomach, I strongly advise anyone to check their trigger warnings before reading.
At the beginning I had a few moments of hesitance, never one to enjoy moments of
I can't say which character this is without spoiling, but she ended up being my favorite. This is an example of how strong and well written the prose is, one of my favorite quotes: ...In the gaps between her teeth, she holds bitterness and rage, the kind that has built with resentment for years...She is the moon, tethered forever to a planet that she does not want anything to do with but can't exist without."
The threads of classism, racism, and misogyny all tied around exquisitely written prose delighted my eyes and enraptured my mind. The story truly just got stronger as the book went on, and the tense and thrilling moments had my heart racing as fast as Adina's. One of my favorite characters was
What I liked most about this book was how biting and honest it was. Casual racism is an every day reality for many people (me included!) and to see how it was depicted so nearly subtly in a way that if you weren't familiar with some of the microaggressions you might think it was just an uncomfortable situation or think nothing of it. (Of course I would hope the more overt and direct racism instances in the book would open any reader's eyes who would dare to think otherwise, or even heaven forbid think this book as something else.)
I need to take a moment to talk about the ending, because it wasn't what I expected, nor have come to expect from books in this vein and I was more than pleasantly surprised.
One more side note I want to add, should Joelle Wellington ever endeavor to pen an adult novel with romance, I would be first in line. The romance moments in this book well, let's just say I would very much love for more.
This is my first book of Joelle Wellington's, and with this quality of writing and storytelling I know it won't be last. Highly recommend.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Misogyny, Bullying, Blood, Classism, Racism, and Violence
Sunbringer by Hannah Kaner
adventurous
emotional
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
My only regret is I'll never be able to read this for the first time again.
Fantasy, representation, writing that makes you feel every emotion the characters do as if it were your own, Sunbringer had me enthralled from the very first page, must like its predecessor, Godkiller. Even as I sit here trying to type a coherent review after Kaner so expertly punched me in the gut with the plot in the last few chapters (A pattern in her writing, which I love, and hate with equal measure!), my mind keeps racing over the events and prose of the story and what might come next.
Every character, new and old, is wonderfully fleshed out in this book, all so painfully and wonderfully human just trying to do what they think is best with what they know, and all in grief. A stand out pov from this is Elogast, while I loved in the first book, I loved him even more in this one. It was such a stark difference to read how much his actions and emotions have changed after the ending of the last book. A man in grief, who knows what he has to do, but he's still torn because of love he feels. Yet he soldiers on. And truly, he does soldier, for this book truly shines a light on how far he was willing to go, and what actions he took when he did fight in the war.Him constantly viewing it like a game board, and being several moves ahead was cold, calculating, and near scary. A hero he was considered, we truly find out what makes a hero during battle. It's terribly, horribly, sad. Just let the man bake his bread and be happy! (I ate up every second!) This book really did feel more Elogast centered then the last, not that I am complaining, given how the plot went, it made sense. I love how so often during Arren's pov, he would think things like; "Some lilac, sweetly scented. Elo's favourite." Showing just how often Elo is on his mind.
I loved every other characters as well, Kissen you have my heart always. There is of course, that fantastic disability and queer representation just like in the last book, a quote I loved from Elogast's pov; "He was not broken. He was never broken. Kissen had taught him that." Naia is a new character, and I really loved reading about a trans character and how that fits into a world of magic gods, and what that would look like. Skedi is another character who goes through a lot of growth, and we get to see a different side of him. He chose to be by Inara's side instead of begin among worshippers. He seems to have finally realized the hurt of his actions, I liked seeing him get offerings tied to his antlers.
For those who seek romance with their fantasy, I would say this book has plenty of platonic love and romantic love, though don't expect the romance like the last book. (Which didn't bother me at all, I think it was perfect.) It really is a darker book, and while there were longing glances, flirtations, and other angst, thereunion I so desperately waited for the entire book didn't happen till the end. Yes, I do want Kissen and Elogast to end up together and take in Inara. Screw Inara's mother, I don't trust her one bit, she seems to have her own goals and manipulations in plan.)
My top scenes that made me have an emotional reaction:The gods falling in battle, Beloris killing his father and Captain Faroch having to attack Elogast, Kissen watching the statue being built and the worshippers become frenzied, the archivists turning on Telle, Kissen landing in a pig shit, most of Elogast's scenes (he really stole the scene a lot), the Arren reveal with the double.
Some of my theories/hopes for the next book;I think Inara's mother is going to die. I really do, just because the angst of Inara just getting her back, it will make it all the more bitter. Though maybe it's because I want her to die that I think that way.
Lots of delicious angst between Elogast and Arren. First of all, screw Arren, he doesn't deserve the wonderful bread knight. Arren is truly a monster, his disregard for children and all of his evil actions...just he needs to die, and I'm upset that he won't.
I do want Kissen to be delightfully herself as always, and very much come punch Arren in the face. At least once. Okay, maybe twice. Also if she could punch Inara's mom.
More godblood coming forward, I predict we will see more and more characters who have godblood in them, and maybe one will be on the enemy side.
Skedi gets a shrine, but doesn't leave Inara. Considering Skedi used to travel and always be by Inara's father's side, I can see this happening, though I wouldn't put it past Kaner to do something angsty and have Skedi killed, and come back without his memories.
Kissen and Legs reunite. Make it happen or I'm protesting. I will be SOBBING when this happens.
Beloris better die, I hope Elogast kills him. I feel so bad for Captain Faroch, that scene was one of the ones that had me crying. (I spent most of this book in a state of anxiety/sobbing).
I do predict there will be WAR. Heavy on the death and bloodshed, I hope a major character doesn't die, just let them be heavily traumatized but stay alive please. I do foresee Elogast having to step up and take a bigger place in it that he will want, considering how strategic and smart he is.
Inara will likely have a big role to play, and her mother will try to manipulate her for her own goals.
Sunbringer took my breath away. Every page, every chapter, I devoured with such intensity, I couldn't have stopped reading if I wanted to. I am always wary of sequels, especially ones that are the follow up to a book that was my top read of 2023 out of the 200+ book I read. It didn't disappoint it was gut wrenchingly perfect. Read it.
No one tell Tolkien, but I favor this series over Lotr.
A MUST read book, start with Godkiller, then read this one, this continues to be the greatest book series I've ever read.
Thank you Harper Voyager for this ARC
Fantasy, representation, writing that makes you feel every emotion the characters do as if it were your own, Sunbringer had me enthralled from the very first page, must like its predecessor, Godkiller. Even as I sit here trying to type a coherent review after Kaner so expertly punched me in the gut with the plot in the last few chapters (A pattern in her writing, which I love, and hate with equal measure!), my mind keeps racing over the events and prose of the story and what might come next.
Every character, new and old, is wonderfully fleshed out in this book, all so painfully and wonderfully human just trying to do what they think is best with what they know, and all in grief. A stand out pov from this is Elogast, while I loved in the first book, I loved him even more in this one. It was such a stark difference to read how much his actions and emotions have changed after the ending of the last book. A man in grief, who knows what he has to do, but he's still torn because of love he feels. Yet he soldiers on. And truly, he does soldier, for this book truly shines a light on how far he was willing to go, and what actions he took when he did fight in the war.
I loved every other characters as well, Kissen you have my heart always. There is of course, that fantastic disability and queer representation just like in the last book, a quote I loved from Elogast's pov; "He was not broken. He was never broken. Kissen had taught him that." Naia is a new character, and I really loved reading about a trans character and how that fits into a world of magic gods, and what that would look like. Skedi is another character who goes through a lot of growth, and we get to see a different side of him.
For those who seek romance with their fantasy, I would say this book has plenty of platonic love and romantic love, though don't expect the romance like the last book. (Which didn't bother me at all, I think it was perfect.) It really is a darker book, and while there were longing glances, flirtations, and other angst, the
My top scenes that made me have an emotional reaction:
Some of my theories/hopes for the next book;
Lots of delicious angst between Elogast and Arren. First of all, screw Arren, he doesn't deserve the wonderful bread knight. Arren is truly a monster, his disregard for children and all of his evil actions...just he needs to die, and I'm upset that he won't.
I do want Kissen to be delightfully herself as always, and very much come punch Arren in the face. At least once. Okay, maybe twice. Also if she could punch Inara's mom.
More godblood coming forward, I predict we will see more and more characters who have godblood in them, and maybe one will be on the enemy side.
Skedi gets a shrine, but doesn't leave Inara. Considering Skedi used to travel and always be by Inara's father's side, I can see this happening, though I wouldn't put it past Kaner to do something angsty and have Skedi killed, and come back without his memories.
Kissen and Legs reunite. Make it happen or I'm protesting. I will be SOBBING when this happens.
Beloris better die, I hope Elogast kills him. I feel so bad for Captain Faroch, that scene was one of the ones that had me crying. (I spent most of this book in a state of anxiety/sobbing).
I do predict there will be WAR. Heavy on the death and bloodshed, I hope a major character doesn't die, just let them be heavily traumatized but stay alive please. I do foresee Elogast having to step up and take a bigger place in it that he will want, considering how strategic and smart he is.
Inara will likely have a big role to play, and her mother will try to manipulate her for her own goals.
Sunbringer took my breath away. Every page, every chapter, I devoured with such intensity, I couldn't have stopped reading if I wanted to. I am always wary of sequels, especially ones that are the follow up to a book that was my top read of 2023 out of the 200+ book I read. It didn't disappoint it was gut wrenchingly perfect. Read it.
No one tell Tolkien, but I favor this series over Lotr.
A MUST read book, start with Godkiller, then read this one, this continues to be the greatest book series I've ever read.
Thank you Harper Voyager for this ARC
Content Warnings
Graphic: Injury/Injury detail, Violence, War, Death, Murder, Grief, and Blood
Moderate: Child death
Minor: Classism, Child abuse, Ableism, and Animal death
Critical Role: The Mighty Nein Origins: Yasha Nydoorin by Cecil Castellucci, Ashley Johnson, Matthew Mercer
adventurous
challenging
dark
emotional
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.0
A gripping and tense tale, but too often the weak art and lack of dynamic composition distracts from the story, resulting in graphic novel that fails to deliver.
I enjoyed getting to see more of Yasha's backstory, it was interesting to see how rough she was raised, and the survival mindset that was forced on her from a very young age. I wish I was able to stay focused on the writing and the characters, but too many times my eyes were instead drawn to the blocky art, and squiggles that took place of feet. There is a key difference between having a style, and just not being good at art. In order to have a developed style, you have to at least understand basic anatomy and how to make the style work so the art is still understandable by the viewer. There are numerous times throughout the novel that the character's faces and features are inconsistent, and often just seem rushed or put as an afterthought. The number of panels were instead of feet there is just a random blocky squiggle, each foot depiction differs.
Other graphic novels in this series showcase excellent composition and varied art boxes. They incorporate the pages into the design and showcase movement, and strong technical skills. It's odd to see such a departure for this character, no matter how rough the background or gruff the character it truly feels like justice was not done for Yasha's backstory.
Overall I would not recommend this to anyone to buy, the cover feels like a severe departure from the actual art of the book. The copy I purchased was sealed, and I was unable to see what it looked like before I bought it. I recommend it from the library, or if you are a die hard Yasha fan, otherwise save your money.
I enjoyed getting to see more of Yasha's backstory, it was interesting to see how rough she was raised, and the survival mindset that was forced on her from a very young age. I wish I was able to stay focused on the writing and the characters, but too many times my eyes were instead drawn to the blocky art, and squiggles that took place of feet. There is a key difference between having a style, and just not being good at art. In order to have a developed style, you have to at least understand basic anatomy and how to make the style work so the art is still understandable by the viewer. There are numerous times throughout the novel that the character's faces and features are inconsistent, and often just seem rushed or put as an afterthought. The number of panels were instead of feet there is just a random blocky squiggle, each foot depiction differs.
Other graphic novels in this series showcase excellent composition and varied art boxes. They incorporate the pages into the design and showcase movement, and strong technical skills. It's odd to see such a departure for this character, no matter how rough the background or gruff the character it truly feels like justice was not done for Yasha's backstory.
Overall I would not recommend this to anyone to buy, the cover feels like a severe departure from the actual art of the book. The copy I purchased was sealed, and I was unable to see what it looked like before I bought it. I recommend it from the library, or if you are a die hard Yasha fan, otherwise save your money.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Blood and Violence
Forged by Magic by Jenna Wolfhart
adventurous
lighthearted
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? N/A
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.25
A cozy, light read full of magic, romance, and dragons, my only complaint it was over all too soon.
The world building and the lore in Forged by Magic is one of my favorite parts. The lush setting and extensive history makes the land and people feel real and vibrant. Daella and Rivelin have great chemistry, I love how they took time to get together and weren't instantly sleeping together. When they did get together it was STEAMY! Towards the middle and end I did find a bit of with the pacing. The ending and the plot felt rushed, I wish there was more of a chance for Daella to showcase her battle prowess and for a confrontation with the emperor. There almost felt like a bit of disconnect from the end and the rest of the book. The miscommunication that occurs also felt very out of character for the side characters.
There is another book in the series, and I will definitely be reading that next!
Overall this is a light and cozy read, and a perfect story for anyone looking for a sweet fantasy.
The cover is amazing! Honestly the whole reason I picked up this book through KU is because the cover caught my eye. I love the composition, color, and how well depicted the characters are.
The world building and the lore in Forged by Magic is one of my favorite parts. The lush setting and extensive history makes the land and people feel real and vibrant. Daella and Rivelin have great chemistry, I love how they took time to get together and weren't instantly sleeping together. When they did get together it was STEAMY! Towards the middle and end I did find a bit of with the pacing. The ending and the plot felt rushed, I wish there was more of a chance for Daella to showcase her battle prowess and for a confrontation with the emperor. There almost felt like a bit of disconnect from the end and the rest of the book. The miscommunication that occurs also felt very out of character for the side characters.
There is another book in the series, and I will definitely be reading that next!
Overall this is a light and cozy read, and a perfect story for anyone looking for a sweet fantasy.
The cover is amazing! Honestly the whole reason I picked up this book through KU is because the cover caught my eye. I love the composition, color, and how well depicted the characters are.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Sexual content
Minor: Confinement, Injury/Injury detail, Blood, and Violence
Starter Villain by John Scalzi
funny
lighthearted
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.5
3.5 stars
Why was I bored reading a book about sentient cats and dolphins?
Strong beginning, but overall it lost momentum as the story went on. The cover had me hooked, as did the blurb. Super villains, talking dolphins, Starter Villain sounded like the perfect humorous book to read, plus it has cats! But at times it was a slog to get through, and the ending overall left me feeling "meh".
For most of the book I did chuckle and enjoy myself immensely. I was pulled into this fantasy world that John Scalzi had masterfully weaved for most of the story. But my issue isn't with "most" of the story. My issue is with the times the pacing dragged, and the dialogue had me rereading sentences because it was so dull. Let me say this. If I wanted to learn about stocks, liquid assets, or other topics in that same vein, I would go read a book about the economy or stock markets. The irony of the book trying to comment on how cis and male dominated the villain sector is and yet the book in itself is very much the same way was not lost on me. The only prominent lady character is Morrison, unless you're counting the fact that all the cat servant/spies/intelligence gatherers are also female. At that point it's like why are we pointing this out? Why even comment on the fact that the villain industry is sexist and old fashioned if your book is written the very same way?
There were definitely some plot holes, pertaining to Charlie and his Uncle. (Though it definitely felt in character!) Quite frankly Charlie the main character could have easily not been a part of this story whatsoever and it would have been all the better for it. (Indeed, was he even really needed at all?) In that same vein Morrison could have easily had someone take his place and act in his stead. (Don't tell me that isn't possible, there were LITERALLY talking dolphins!) Charlie seemed almost too perfect, and lacked character flaws. He easily deduced so many plans, and was able to navigate a situation based on random experiences and jobs he has had. A lot of times it just didn't make sense and felt like he was too perfect. A substitute teacher all of a sudden able to masterfully navigate nearly every aspect of "villain" life? It almost reads as self-insert.
If the book had focused more on what it seemed to be about according to the book jacket, and less about exposition and stocks and the men being shitty, I might have enjoyed it more. I wanted to see more about the experiments and dolphins, and cats. More about how shitty the villains are and the negative consequences they have on regular people. Charlie came out of the story seemingly untraumatized and remarkably unphased. As it stands I find myself shaking my head in disappointment at another male dominated science fiction story.
The ending was...a choice. For a book that seemed to hinge so much on Charlie taking over the business, and even marketing it as that, I expected that to happen. Maybe Charlie would grow a conscious and dissolve the business and be a better person. Instead he just opens a pub and goes on with his life. A more realistic ending I would have liked better, is if he failed at the pub. Or ended up hating it. Food service is not for the weak of heart and Charlie seems to have romanticized it greatly. If he had come crawling back to Morrison and co. at the end and started working for a villain in some capacity, or doing something like that, it would have made more sense. Again, are we forgetting that Charlie saw so many people murdered! And again he has no trouble adjusting to normal society?
Why such a harsh review? I was so excited to read this. This is also nearly a $30 book that is only about 250 pages hardcover. So you can see why I'm a bit salty. If you like primarily science fiction books by male authors, this is for you. If not, skip it, I wouldn't recommend it.
Why was I bored reading a book about sentient cats and dolphins?
Strong beginning, but overall it lost momentum as the story went on. The cover had me hooked, as did the blurb. Super villains, talking dolphins, Starter Villain sounded like the perfect humorous book to read, plus it has cats! But at times it was a slog to get through, and the ending overall left me feeling "meh".
For most of the book I did chuckle and enjoy myself immensely. I was pulled into this fantasy world that John Scalzi had masterfully weaved for most of the story. But my issue isn't with "most" of the story. My issue is with the times the pacing dragged, and the dialogue had me rereading sentences because it was so dull. Let me say this. If I wanted to learn about stocks, liquid assets, or other topics in that same vein, I would go read a book about the economy or stock markets. The irony of the book trying to comment on how cis and male dominated the villain sector is and yet the book in itself is very much the same way was not lost on me. The only prominent lady character is Morrison, unless you're counting the fact that all the cat servant/spies/intelligence gatherers are also female. At that point it's like why are we pointing this out? Why even comment on the fact that the villain industry is sexist and old fashioned if your book is written the very same way?
There were definitely some plot holes, pertaining to Charlie and his Uncle. (Though it definitely felt in character!) Quite frankly Charlie the main character could have easily not been a part of this story whatsoever and it would have been all the better for it. (Indeed, was he even really needed at all?) In that same vein Morrison could have easily had someone take his place and act in his stead. (Don't tell me that isn't possible, there were LITERALLY talking dolphins!) Charlie seemed almost too perfect, and lacked character flaws. He easily deduced so many plans, and was able to navigate a situation based on random experiences and jobs he has had. A lot of times it just didn't make sense and felt like he was too perfect. A substitute teacher all of a sudden able to masterfully navigate nearly every aspect of "villain" life? It almost reads as self-insert.
If the book had focused more on what it seemed to be about according to the book jacket, and less about exposition and stocks and the men being shitty, I might have enjoyed it more. I wanted to see more about the experiments and dolphins, and cats. More about how shitty the villains are and the negative consequences they have on regular people. Charlie came out of the story seemingly untraumatized and remarkably unphased. As it stands I find myself shaking my head in disappointment at another male dominated science fiction story.
The ending was...a choice.
Why such a harsh review? I was so excited to read this. This is also nearly a $30 book that is only about 250 pages hardcover. So you can see why I'm a bit salty. If you like primarily science fiction books by male authors, this is for you. If not, skip it, I wouldn't recommend it.
Content Warnings
Minor: Misogyny, Sexism, Fire/Fire injury, Murder, Death of parent, Death, and Blood