Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
3.5
I loved the first book, but had a harder time with the second installment (partially because this is much darker--see content warnings). There are more POV in this book, which I wasn't as invested in from the first book, and because of that, I felt like it bogged the story down. I loved that Zhu and Ouyang teamed up and I wanted more from Ma's perspective, especially given how instrumental her story is in the last part of the book.
I know this is a duology, but I kind of wish there was a third, so we could see if Zhu lives up to expectations as Emperor. Was all the sacrifice worth it? Not knowing anything about the Ming Empire, I was left wanting more and the story feels unfinished.
Graphic: Misogyny, Murder, Pregnancy, Self harm, Sexual assault, Sexual content, Blood, War, Body horror, Injury/Injury detail, Physical abuse, Violence, Body shaming, Death, Outing, Gore, Homophobia, Sexual violence, Child death, Grief, Rape, Slavery, and Torture
I was hooked by Hannah's story, but felt like the 1930s storyline really dragged the plot down. The ending of Hannah's timeline felt like the author didn't know what to do with her story, which is why the 1930s timeline was added. I would have enjoyed a book that was just about Hannah's pirate adventures amongst real historic individuals; I was so invested in Hannah's story that I felt Marian's betrayal when she discovered that Hannah wasn't real. It was redeemed a bit in my eyes by the fact that the fake story was inspired by an archival find.
A beautifully written book that you'll want to sit with and savor. Science stories interwoven (with creatures you've heard of and others you probably haven't) with personal narrative in an extremely successful format. Essays include: a mother octopus protecting her eggs alongside the author's experience with diet culture; the misinformation of the Bobbitt worm's common name and coming to terms with the author's experiences with sexual assault; analyzing a whale fall in conjunction with the end of one of their first queer relationships; and cuttlefish morphing abilities and bringing in multiple queer voices to explore their complex/changing relationships with their bodies.
Absolutely adored the characters, somewhat predictable plot (but I didn't mind because the characters were so well-rounded). Fantasy set in the "real world" with queer relationships and found family. Similar vibes as "The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches" by Sangu Mandanna.
I loved the book "My Side of the Mountain" growing up, so I loved reading about the actual training of a hawk. I love Mabel and the author's descriptions of her hunting, playing, and reacting to the world. I wasn't as intrigued by the inclusion of T. H. White as a reoccurring facet of the story.