Really gorgeous and definitely benefits a lot from listening to Sinéad’s own voice narrating it. Hearing her still able to laugh and giggle and reflect after all she’s been through was just such a lovely experience and I’m glad I got to hear her story in her own words. The ending feels bittersweet now hearing how hopeful she was about her new album and touring again after COVID completely shut everything down. Some highlights are definitely her story about meeting (and having a crush on) a tour guide she met in Lourdes as a young girl and how she’s able to look back now at the abuse she endured at the hands of her mother and no longer feel rage but instead compassion for her mother’s mental illness.
There’s ZERO chemistry between Millie and Enzo as well as Millie and Brock.
The voice acting is atrocious. Again, still not at all what a Brooklyn accent sounds like and Enzo’s “Italian” accent borders on parody. And as if that wasn’t bad enough, apparently there’s no editing done for this audiobook because the actress mispronounces the most basic words (regardless of which character is speaking).
Millie is by far the stupidest protagonist I’ve ever had the misfortune of reading about. I think the author chose to make Millie a “tough” former convict to make up for giving her literally no personality but at no point is it believable. If Millie was railroaded by the justice system before, why would she have such extreme trust and confidence in the NYPD? And how does she have ZERO street smarts?
I feel like everything from the last book was completely just written out aside from the laughable romance between Millie and Enzo (despite them having zero chemistry), who in this book the author turned into a complete and total moron. Wow, he keeps calling her boyfriend “Broccoli” instead of Brock. So funny. 🙄
Also the author is dreadful at world building. No descriptions of pretty much anything. “He hands me a dress.” Okay, what does the dress look like? Or feel like?
None of this believably sounds like New York. Any actual New Yorker would tell you that nobody just drives in and out of the Boroughs all the time as much as Enzo and Millie and Brock do. Most New Yorkers don’t even have cars due to the shoddy parking situation (unless they’re commuting often to Long Island which literally nobody but Douglas seems to do). And each time Millie had to say how she lives in the South Bronx like five times per sentence, I just cringed.
The big “twist” made zero sense. Especially considering Millie’s boyfriend is a lawyer? Why not go to him sooner once you’ve figured out that you’ve never actually met Douglas before!?
I just can not for the life of me figure out why any of this author’s books are so highly rated because honestly it’s giving amateur hour.
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
2.5
The narrator was awful (begging more voice actors to learn what an actual Brooklyn accent sounds like. Also she outright just didn’t know how to pronounce simple words? Is there no editing in Audiobooks?) and both Millie and Nina were competing in the Pick Me! Olympics and were really frustrating to read about because they both felt so completely underdeveloped .
It’s weird how little detail McFadden gives us. Is this a new trend? Taylor Jenkins Reid writes like this too. They just assume “a large, expensive looking room” or “white pants” are enough when none of that actually paints a picture for me as a reader. There was more detail (like ten pages worth) and description when Nina accidentally squirts breast milk everywhere at work than there is like anything else in this book.
Also Millie’s backstory makes zero sense to me. You’d think someone who spent 10 years in prison would have more street smarts and common sense but no. She makes the most absurd mistakes.
And she really leans HARD into the whole “pick me!” NLOG thing. It was hard not to roll my eyes every time she said something along the lines of “Nina is an ugly fat bitch unlike me who is sexy and petite and model gorgeous (despite doing 10 years in prison then living in my car for months) but also young and fertile.” Like girl, STAND UP. Have some self respect lmfao. No man is worth it. Especially not the blank void of a character that is Andrew (we just know he’s hot but we’re never given much description part that and even before shit gets crazy, he has no personality at all).
Nina and Enzo’s scheme also makes ZERO sense. And is pretty revolting tbh. It’s weird that they both really thought setting up another woman to be tortured by Andrew was a good idea. This is another example of an author being so wrapped up in having a twist that they forgot how to actually develop one that makes sense.
This was a fast listen and entertaining enough so 2.5 stars is I think an adequate rating but yeah, the author has a lot of work to do before writing anything else 😬
Actually feels like a real biography and the author does a great job mixing the real world with her own alternate version of history to really convince you of X and this story. Speaking of the alternate United States of this book, I like that it wasn’t spelled out right away but a gradual reveal about 10% or so into the book. It was like a punch in the gut once the Southern Territory was revealed.
Also a really gorgeous portrait of a woman (the fictional author) struggling to make sense of not only her marriage but of the abuse she endured and whether or not it was true (like some of the folks she interviews seem to be suggesting) that *her* suffering and the way she was treated was justified because it fueled art.
It’s common for victims to blame themselves or feel like they deserved to be treated badly or were lucky to be with their abusive but often more charismatic partner.
Just a really, really thought provoking book and I think it’s going to stay with me for awhile.
A really great premise (especially as a film buff) but not scary enough for me, unfortunately. I also really didn’t buy the love story at the end. I preferred Tristán and Momo’s dynamic as a friendship.
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
2.0
This was a massive disappointment for me. I remember seeing the cover ages ago and immediately adding it to my reading list. Then I heard folks talking about and figured I had to give it a shot eventually and when I heard it was a re-telling of The Fall of the House of Usher I figured now would be the perfect time to read it since I just watched (and LOVED) the Netflix series. Well…this was nowhere near as good as I was hoping it would be. Painfully slow (which is outrageous considering how short it is) and dreadfully boring until I hit the 58% mark. All of the characters are either completely bland or in Easton’s case, unbelievably irritating. Yes, books at that time were a bit on the dry side but oh my god there’s no reason to do that with a retelling written now. I don’t need the constant war memories or lectures on Gallacian pronouns. There was some promise here first with the rabbits and then eventually once we’re told what is going on with Madeline but that all happens so quickly it sucked any and all tension right out of the book. Also what the fuck is up with the weird Beatrix Potter fanfic thrown in? I’ve heard only good things about this author so it’s a shame that I disliked this so much but maybe I’ll give them another chance.
This was so beautifully written and really humanizes Britney Spears. Despite all of her suffering, Britney was able to still remain kind and empathetic (yet honest and apologetic about moments where she wasn’t the kindest). She still can see joy and hope in life and that makes me happy for her. Michelle Williams did an excellent job reading this. Definitely worth the hype.
Yeah this was just…fine? It seemed pretty fair and balanced but I have to say, the story of Glossier (as told here anyway) isn’t all that riveting or unique. This served more to me as a fun recollection of the early 2010’s beauty culture and reminded me of my own experiences with Into the Gloss or first discovering Glossier’s products in college. Maybe it’s because Emily Weiss is so guarded and careful about her image, but yeah…nothing here felt particularly surprising.