this little story is SO engaging!! the weaving of Polish myth with modern-day Chicago was really cool, and the characterizations, especially Dymitr, were so whole despite such little space. it's also rare that I find myself both grossed out and a little afraid, but the whole concept of a bone sword... incredible. I cannot WAIT for the next installment!!
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.5
would I have been happy if it had ended here? yep, entirely so. and given the fact that I'm writing this after finishing book 5, which for me had a whole host of issues I'm dying to debate, I stand by this even more. it would have been convenient though, and I understand why certain things had to happen. just know that in an ideal world, you-know-who would've gotten in a few more tricks before making an exit and you-know-who would have come out unscathed AS THEY DESERVE.
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.25
our epic conclusion...
tbh, I saw a LOT of this coming. the twists and turns, maybe not, but the ultimate outcome? yep, tracked that from book 3(?). I'll be honest, Morgan deserved better, and so did Wolfe. instead of having her go down in a blaze of glory, Wolfe's father should have stepped up to defend the great archives—2 obscurists is better than 1, and he had so much to atone for doing nothing and leaving his son to suffer at the hands of the former Artifex Magnus—alongside her, even if he was injured. if the most important part of the library is under siege, you would think the Obscurist Magnus should be there to help; just because the Iron Tower was compromised at one point doesn't mean the he was the ONLY one there capable of defending it. that's such a disservice to the other obscurists and to Morgan. as such, I'm pretty bitter about the ending. I know that this is how it goes, especially in YA series, that someone beloved has to die, but the way it was done really irks me.. there were still moments I really liked, though. in particular, Thomas's time in the tomb of Heron was super cool. in another life, I would have wanted an entire spin-off series about Thomas and his engineering career; his brain is one I would die to root around in.
overall, despite the shortcomings of this ending, I really loved this series. the audiobooks were very engaging and made a 5-book series feel like blip of time. I absolutely WILL be peddling this series to everyone I know that enjoys a good dystopia.
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.5
obviously everything previously hasn't exactly been a walk in the park... but something about this installment was miserable—and by that I mean dark, depraved, emphasizing the worst part of war. the blatant disrepect for human life was neither under- nor overstated; it felt very real and very cruel, and it hurt to read about. And that ending?? man, this series does not let you breathe but I am LOVING it.
I really enjoyed this installment, despite the fact that there were several things that felt very convenient, particularly with regard to Morgan. I know we're in Jess's POV so technically he doesn't know anything either, but it's kind of frustrating to get no real background about how things are being done. On the other hand, I loved the strengthened friendship between Jess and Glain, the character arc of Wolfe's mother, Morgan's agony being back in the Iron Tower, the slight plot twist in the Black Archives that had me gasping, and the new location we'll be visiting in the next installment. Overall, I am still having so much fun reading these!
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.0
what can I say, other than I'm so happy to have finally picked up this series! it has a very nostalgic, old school adventure/action movie kind of vibe—think The Mummy or Indiana Jones but with a literary dystopian twist. it's been so long since I read a series where a) the main protagonist is male (this is coincidental, I think??) and b) I knew absolutely nothing going in. I really like Jess as the morally grey but ultimately gold-hearted MMC, and the nuanced cast of side characters. I loved how well-paced the story was (and the fact that for every lull, there was an equal and opposite explosion of action). I didn't mind the romantic subplot; I'm really curious to see how things develop now that they're where they are. Overall, I've been left confused and kinda stressed but itching for more (hence my already starting #2 before even writing this review lol).
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.25
this was quite different than I was expecting, but that wasn't a bad thing! it gave me strong Prydain Chronicles meets The Two Princesses of Bamarre meets the rambling quest sections of The Lord of the Rings—all that to say, a very magical and dark(ish) atmosphere coupled with young-minded/stubborn characters that go from being stuck in their ways to learning they can be much more. it definitely reads like YA, but in a whimsical way, not immature. the rhymes, especially, really drove home the vibe of the story. and that description of the dyke breaking?? I was in tears. it felt so nostalgic and powerful, like a true homecoming and made my heart so happy. most importantly, though, I had a good time; I would definitely consider picking up more from this author in the future!
this was super imaginative and such a great concept, but it felt very lacking in the end. "Healing fiction" has become a very popular genre these days, particularly in Korea, so I was hoping for something more along those lines, with more heartfelt lessons to be learned alongside all the fantastical elements. instead, it was a lot more simple than I was expecting. not necessarily a bad thing, just not what I'd hoped for.
just as the moniker "healing fiction" would suggest, this book is slow, meandering, and rumative; it's about vibes and lessons, not a real plot. there's a lot to learn about books, or rather bookselling, but also about work-life balance, choosing a vocation, making friends, putting yourself first, depression and anxiety, comparing yourself to others, giving yourself grace, taking a vacation, and finding the places that your heart calls home. and most of it unconscious. the author's note rings true by the end: amongst all the musings and tendrils of wisdom, each character, despite feeling lost or uncertain or anxious, inches forward a step or two. they are always moving forward, even when, to society, it looks like they're standing still.