It's rare when I can't find anything to appreciate in a story. This book was repetitive to the point of infuriating. A slew of on the nose moments, pacing isssues, and a plot hole that should have been fixed during the planning stage. To top it off, I didn't like one character in the book.
I listened to the audiobook and the narrator's performance was excellent, but it couldn't make up for the poor writing.
We read this for book club. It's not my tea, but it was interesting.
My major issue was the treatment of a character as a plot device. He was easily the most interesting and sympathetic character, but we knew almost nothing about him, and he was introduced and taken away to further the sisters' story. If the novel had been about HIS disappearance and his rediscovery 20 years later, I would have loved the story.
My take is that the author felt she needed significant shared trauma to pull off the story. Both of the girls had plenty without this character's demise.
Azuma, the teenaged son of a deceased kimono maker, falls for the mysterious Matsuoka--a man who insists on caring for Azuma and his sickly mother, saying he is only paying back a kindness. As he falls in love, Azuma grows jealous of his father's memory, believing that he was Matsuoka's savior, but his eyes are opened in more than one way when he visits Matsuoka in Tokyo.
My absolute favorite by Asou Mitsuaki. I own it in Japanese. Her works are all so melancholy and beautiful. I'd do anything for another chapter of these two.
Matsuoka is a gangster and at one point is shown cutting off someone's ear. There's also a flashback scene where he's ostensibly working as a prostitute.
Best friends become something more thanks to a pair of black stockings.
Not my favorite Scarlet Beriko (that honor goes to Queen and the Tailor), but it's a one-shot I have on my Kobo, so I reread it when I need a boost.
Head's up for a homophobic (closeted) character and a high school student dating the school nurse. And Jackass! is getting a sequel! Scarlet talked about it during FujoCon last year.
This is my favorite book. I re-read it every few years and my feelings toward it evolve as I get older. I like the movie adaptation just fine, but the book's ending is so much more satisfying, even though Kitty gets to deliver that zinger in the film.
The book is about a woman who has been defined by her looks since youth, coming to learn what's actually important to her--and who.
Head's up for racism on Kitty's part when she's in China.