This kind of book is right up my alley but I really struggled to follow this. I was listening on audio, so don't know if that was a contributing factor but I felt like the narrative structure was confusing, especially with the way the book started, and I struggled to tell the characters apart and remember who was who or what the key parts of the fraud were. I might check out the Netflix show now as that'll probably help solidify the narrative in my head.
I really enjoyed this book and was hooked from the get-go, but I never felt fully connected to the characters or invested in certain relationships and parts of the story/setup never quite clicked for me.
An overall great listen on audio, though the structure felt a bit messy — the true crime scams combined with the memoirs felt random, and the transitions abrupt, at times — and I didn't really care for the self-help parts. Still, engaging and entertaining for sure!
What a great, quick read. The writing really worked for me — so straightforward and yet evocative. Real tense at times, too, and reading it around Christmas was perfect.
I'm not sure what I think about this book but I was intrigued all the way through so that counts for something. I can see why people say: "What was that? Nothing happened. So boring." but I really appreciated the novel concept/perspective and wanted to know where it was going. The conclusion of one of the main story lines left me frustrated and unsatisfied though!
Loved the premise but the execution fell short! Some of the ways the characters spoke to one another and behaved didn't make sense given the history of the relationships. And come the end I was left wanting: wanting a bit more of an explanation as to what was going on and why, for one! It all felt rushed and unclear.
This book wins points for me as I'm a Glossier fan and I'm intrigued by Emily Weiss. However, I was hoping for something more interesting here. It was clear why the book existed. There wasn't really a groundbreaking revelation or any juicy BTS bits. The blurb says it's a "bombshell exposé" and...it just isn't. Still, I appreciated the little peek behind the curtain we did get.
This is a reread eight years later and wow, what a fantastic book! Now that I'm older, wiser, and have lived through a pandemic, I could appreciate it even more than the first time I read it. The writing is wonderful and the shifting perspectives and timelines work so well together to create an immersive tale. Can't wait to finally read some other St. John Mandel books!
(My review eight years ago was a 4. Upped it to 4.5. Didn't quite get to that rare 5-star "je ne sais quoi"/magic for me.)