Overall, I think this was a decent debut novel and it was set up well to be the first book in a series.
At first, the romance aspect of the book didn’t seem natural, but then in the second half of the book I COMPLETELY understood why…and I liked the little twist in direction! This is definitely a slow burn for the romance aspect, and it was set up to traverse multiple books which I love!
In the first book, the FMC is thrust into a magical world separate from earth. We see her come to the understanding that humans in this realm are slaves, meet some elvish royalty, go on mini heists, and travel through multiple courts…all in attempts to discover how she fits into an old, mysterious prophecy.
At times, I will say that the writing style read like a YA novel and was a bit repetitive, but the contents of the book were mature/new adult…which was a little strange to me. It also took me awhile to form a connection to the characters, but as I said before, the story was set up well for a second book!
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
3.25
I was so hyped for this book and the first half of it was good! I was invested in figuring out why “Nyra” ran away from her home and how she would navigate being with the rebel group. However, I feel like once the spice component entered the picture, the plot went straight out the window for the remainder of the book. Although I understand this is a short book and the first in a series, I was looking for some more world building and character development before it got hot and heavy. Even though I thought the spice came too quickly, I did enjoy the first couple scenes! However, I found myself getting bored once it because just spice scene after spice scene with no progression through the actual story really. To be honest, I was thankful for the cliffhanger at the end because it makes me hopeful that we will get back to the plot in book two!
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
5.0
Perfection, absolute perfection 🙌
Everyone and their mom has already read this series so my reviews for the books aren’t going to be long.
I heard some people mention that they found the beginning of Caraval slow, and others were just reading this trilogy to prepare for UOABH so I was a little hesitant going into it.
But OH BOY I swear, this is one of my favorite reads of the year. I was hooked from the very beginning and never EVER lost interest throughout this fever dream of a book.
I won’t say too much about this one because I have very similar feelings as I did when I read An Optimist’s Guide to Heartbreak. There were definitely darker tones here which I liked but most of the book was a repeat of Lucy and Cal getting close, then fighting, then getting close, etc…
They have one of the most toxic relationships and by the end, I think I was rooting more for them to finally clear the air rather than them to get together 🤣
Miscommunication tropes are not my thing when it’s the focal point of a story, but that’s just me.
I feel so conflicted. Half the time while reading, my jaw was on the floor and my eyes were glued to the page. The other half of the time, my eyes were in the back of my head from rolling them so dramatically at all the cringy, forced, cliché moments and d*ck jokes. I also found the FMC, Lucy, lowkey insufferable. I understand that she’s supposed to be portrayed as overly innocent to contrast her deep dark feelings and that it’s important for her character development…but it was just too much.
AND YET here I am, rooting for the main characters to get together, and wanting to read book two. That cliff hanger made me so mad but it was set up perfectly for a short duology like this one. Their relationship stresses me out so much but I just can’t stop. What kind of crack is this book laced with???
I just can’t get over the fact that this was a debut book for Nicolle’s new fantasy series…it was amazing!
I had a feeling this would quickly become one of my favorite books this year, and honestly, it might be one of my favorite books PERIOD. I am so incredibly excited for this series to continue!
I highlighted and bookmarked so many pages in my Kindle while reading, from the very first chapter to the last. Usually, I struggle with maintaining attention in fantasy books when a lot of foundational information is being described, but here, the world-building, character descriptions, and dialogue were all equally captivating!
The love story throughout this book is everything I love; it’s not truly enemies-to-lovers, but more of an instant attraction where the FMC is repulsed by her feelings and goes into deep denial for several chapters. And THEN from there, we get a slow burn with tension, fights, and more tension. I can’t wait for their relationship to explode later in the series; it’ll be worth the wait for sure!
The last chapter was also VERY mysterious, and I feel like we are just scratching the surface with whatever adventures Nicolle has planned for our little group of rebels.