rudyb's Reviews (242)


unreliable sexually repressed narrators my beloved <3
challenging dark emotional reflective sad tense

this is the best and most devastating book i have read this year

picked this up on a whim and loved it, i’ve already bought another of alison smith’s collections and can’t wait to get to it
emotional hopeful reflective sad tense medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character

mmmm this one really captured the painful self-awareness that comes w mental illness for me, quick but meaningful read
dark funny tense fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Complicated

the first probably like 75% of this book felt like it was shaping up to be one of my favourite books of the year.  the magical realism and the almost claustrophobic feeling of being inside the mother’s head i thought were so fascinating and just my kind of weird. unfortunately the ending was kind of a let down.
the descriptions of the art show and the reviews and the pr campaign felt too removed from the rest of the book and a little too on the nose for me, satirical intentions or not. it just brought down what was otherwise a very compelling book.
overall i would still recommend it, even if the conclusion didn’t land for me. also u know amy adams is up to her ears in the character study rn so can’t wait for that.

very few writers make me feel the way ivan coyote does. i can’t think of anyone else whose words i connect to more and this collection is no different, i was almost sad when i realized i was finished with it.
medium-paced

picked this up on a whim and really liked it, will probably pick up some more of mcgahern’s works later.
reflective sad

young adulthood is all abt the fear of becoming ur parents huh
emotional hopeful inspiring lighthearted fast-paced

i love this story so much in any format but this one made me want to cry it captured the tone of lm montgomery’s book so perfectly
challenging dark reflective tense medium-paced

i feel like this book is one that will take a while to unravel in my head, post-reading. toews does a great job at communicating the urgency of the situation, which is compelling, but also means that we don't get an in-depth understanding of any of the women's inner worlds. this is compounded by the fact that the book is narrated by the male scribe attending the meetings. i thought this was an interesting choice since it constantly reminds the reader of the power imbalance the women are facing as they are unable to read or write, but, again, it means we don't get the inner monologue of the female characters.