Sweet little fantasy slice of life. Feels like playing low stakes dungeons and dragons with your childhood friends. Loved the stable established lesbian relationship, wish the main conflict reached a bit more secure of a resolution, but I understand it’s to set up the rest of the series. Go into this for vibes not plot and you’ll have a great time.
I’ve been looking for a book like this for a long time, I think. A little YA, but an overall very digestible fantasy-sci-fi. While the stakes are technically world-saving-ly high, the reader rarely feels them to be.
If you’re looking for something cozy, this is marketed as a romance, so you count on it for a HEA.
I craved so much more from this book. The writing was beautiful, the relationships believable, characters complex, butchfemme dynamics… but the pacing and the ending especially fell flat for me. I drudged through the first third of the book over the course of several months, but kept giving returning because there is so much that is compelling about this novel. Once the adventure and romance finally began, it was lovely. The ending, however, felt almost as if it belonged to a different story. To pursue a life valuing culture and heritage only to timeskip through four months serving the colonial power in an undescribed civil war with the “happy ending” being a marriage proposal between two characters who hadn’t spoken through all of those months? ughhh
I had a fun time reading this book— in line with fantasy like SJM, you don’t have to do much thinking about the magic system, setting, etc, which is what I wanted when I picked this up. I do wish the author had pushed the boundaries more— big illicit magical gatsby parties call for more wickedness and sex and glitz than this novel permitted.