Fairly entertaining, but reads like a children’s book, and the premise and much of the novel was very predictable (been done before many many times). Also way too much exposition — simple takes on the human condition littered with cliches and empty quotes.
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
3.5
Really enjoyed this sweet, thoughtful, nostalgic YA book! Yes, even though the author markets this as her first adult book, I’d say this is the definition of YA—emotional, full of the energy and anxiety and anticipation and plot twists of youth—with a perspective of the adults in the future who are still young at heart. What have we learned? You can’t change the past. Every moment of your life is real, every day counts. You can’t predict the future. As a college student, I ran a literary magazine, so this cast and setting spoke to my past and filled my memory bank and made me wonder where all my friends ended up twenty five years later! Why the 3.5 stars? The time travel stuff was amusing but felt shallow, in the end—and I think I’m skeptical that adults would behave like such children for such a long time.
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.5
An astonishing collection. The language, the writing, the characters, the plots, the settings, the pacing, all so perfectly crafted. My only complaint is that these stories felt almost too polished, in that late ‘90s overworkshopped vibe. But again and again I finished reading a story with a sigh—amazed at the virtuoso performance of the writer.
After watching the show, I read this book. It’s a somehow calming book despite the post pandemic apocalypse setting. The show took the book almost as a template and complicated each character’s story, enriching (IMO) the original narrative in a way that was not antithetical to the original but really enhanced it. I enjoyed reading what the characters were sensing and thinking, the way the author describes the forest and heightened awareness of the dangerous world. At the end, I felt extremely thankful for what we have.