The plot honestly isn't very coherent but at some point I stopped caring and went along for the ride. And I truly did enjoy reading it. I definitely did NOT see the Puella Magi Madoka Magica ending coming but... you know what, it's fine. I'm just here for the ride. And it was fun. I've also realized I'm a haunted forest horror fan. Can't wait to read more of those
Reading this book felt a little like what Orabella must have felt living in that house - you can't tell the reality and illusions apart, things made sense for a bit then they didn't, the story a fever dream. I can't tell you for sure what really happened, only that it gripped me when I started reading and I wasn't able to put it down.
There was a conversation between two characters near the end of the book that read like criticisms of colonialism and how yt settler colonizers benefited from generations of (stolen) wealth that made me think more about the message of the book. Especially with that ending. Oof. Midnight Rooms is not leaving my mind anytime soon and I only hope it doesn't also show up in my nightmares.
reading slump really kicked my behind but i am so glad i sat down and finished this. i love this series and all the wonders of the world of the Leopard people so much.
There's a lot I did like about this book. I adore Joanna and Walela and I was very invested in Ember's journey, wishing the best for her. Take the romance out and I would still love to read a story entirely about her struggling with her relationships with her family and ultimately making up with them and healing.
And that's probably one of the issues I had with the book: that this is a rom-com and I didn't exactly care about the romance. At least, I didn't dislike it, so I was able to keep reading. But what made this book difficult and even painful for me to read was the secondhand anxiety I was experiencing from reading Ember trying to make sure no one finds out about her lies and her relationship at work. Like literally making out with MMC IN THE OFFICE while the boss stepped out and allegedly wouldn't be back for a while - readers, he was back before the scheduled time. My anxiety was PEAKED and I could not stomach reading it. The blackmailing business genuinely made me lose my will to live - like I know Ember was suffering too but damn if I was in the same situation I would simply end it all. I am not the gods' strongest soldier. The only way I was able to finish this book is by skipping parts that were making me feel to anxious, only skimming enough of it to get a general idea of what happened. I did read the chapters after she was fired in their entirety though. Like I said, I was very invested in her familial bonds.
I would still love to check out the author's next release but this book proved to me that workplace romance simply isn't for me and I should probably stick with historical and fantasy romance!
I'm gonna attempt to actually write a review of this book other than "I AM INCONSOLABLE".
It's not working. I just love Jo and Liza with my whole heart and soul. It is unapologetically queer (featuring a bisexual woman on the aromantic spectrum!), unapologetically pro-sex work, a truly diverse and inclusive romance that paints a realistic picture of the lower-middle class struggles in the Philippines, and so tender and lovable. I love Jo and Liza. (starts weeping)
I am so honoured to have a friend based in the Philippines who was kind enough to purchase the blush books version and mail it to me. I am indebted to her for the rest of my life. JUST LOOK AT THIS COVER. JUST LOOK AT HOW BEAUTIFUL THEY ARE- (weeps even more loudly)
I thought of Wild Thorns often while reading this book. Both books, to quote myself, present the only sort of two sides I care to read about and understand - not that of the colonizer and the colonized, but whether to resist or to give in.
While reading Wild Thorns felt a lot like that "you can only watch" meme (a variation on the trolley problem where you have no access to any switch and can only watch while a train run over a track full of people), reading Beside the Sickle Moon made me felt like... I was the viewer, the conductor of the train and someone tied to the track at the same time. There's not much to say other than it felt so painfully real.
One thing I deeply appreciate about the author is the way he really does not pull any punches. Despite the protagonist's anti-resistance stance, he never stopped referring to the Israeli military as IOF and used the terms "settlers" and "Zionists" to refer to "the Israelis" properly. At one point, the author even made reference to how the CCP treats the Uyghurs and how "Israel" took inspiration from that. Other than the one memoir I read by a Uyghur woman, I cannot remember another book that mentioned the CCP's genocide of the Uyghurs straight up. It is sadly very unknown internationally and a lot of criticisms of the CCP are being painted as buying into the US propaganda which is just... It's a whole another can of worms that I will not open in this review.
If you find yourself feeling lost a chapter or two into the book, just keep reading. Trust me that everything will makes sense, especially as things start unfolding in the second half.
Also, it did NOT have to end like that. That was literally my first text to a friend who recently read the book after I finished: "WHY DID IT END LIKE THAT CRYING EMOJI"
An invaluable, vulnerable and brutally honest book about Palestinian resistance and living under an oppressive regime that I will not forget anytime soon and will be recommending alongside Wild Thorns.
Thank you to the author for providing a review copy! I am honoured to be able to read this story.
Thank you to #netgalley for providing the e-arc. This book was published on April 9th, 2024.
While this book had good information on:
how racism absolutely did NOT end even though "legalized slavery" ended (and on that note: slavery never really ended either, it just took on different forms)
how institutions like banks and universities benefited from slavery and they, along with megarichs, should be the first to foot the cost of reparations, contrary to opponents of reparation claiming that it would be yet another taxpayer burden (like we actual taxpayers got a say in where our taxes go? I WANT my taxes to go towards free school lunches not fucking bombs)
the history of African Americans fighting for their rights and deserved payments + how the US government tried their absolute hardest to weasel out of their obligations
discussions and suggestions of infrastructures that reparations can fund
it wasn't exactly an engaging book and reading it was an frustrating experience. Part of it was due to how technical the language is, though this is not a point of criticism, just something I'd like to point out to new readers.
The book is separated to two parts: part I consists of speeches and documents and part II consists of articles and essays. Part I can be a bit dry due to the nature of those text, but I was also annoyed by the amount of whole lot of nothing languages like thanking the United Nations and the US American president for the progresses made and what an honour it was to have them here and whatever. Those can be easily edited out and nothing of essence would've been lost. Part II was definitely more interesting to read.
I also think part I could benefit from moving Chapter 9 and 10 to the front as those could be good for readers unfamiliar with reparation to go through first (it's me, I'm readers).
Have I mentioned how editing could make this book better? WHY are ISRAEL and REPARATION JUSTICE/SUCCESS mentioned in the same paragraph? TWICE? IN THIS CURRENT CLIMATE? I am not pretending to be a very informed person, since I myself am not educated until after October 2023. But IN TWENTY TWENTY FOUR? I am going to hope that this text is ARC only and the published version does NOT normalize the so-called state of Israel.
Some ableist words have also been used in this book - namely the r-word (as a verb) and "crippling". Yes I know the r-word has other meanings but at this point let's just not. There are other words one can use to mean "going backwards" or "preventing progress". And instead of "crippling", might I suggest "devastating", "undermining", "undercutting", or "defunding"?
reading the physical books after already devoured everything online.
this is easily the funniest manhwa i've ever read and i will love abigail and blanche forever. kudos to the author also for calling out double standards and fatphobia