I had no idea what to expect from this, but was so delighted by it. I don't know anything about modern countryside Japan, so I don't know how authentic it is. I hope, though, that it's more truth than fiction.
I'm sure this was a good book for the intended audience; however, it's the second series in a shared world and I couldn't follow all the horse drama very easily.
This was a really cute book about believing in yourself. It also tackled some struggles of the Jewish people in history. This made me nervous because I know in reality it would have been so much worse; but the book was for kids, so nothing too bad happened.
This is a well written book. I loved the world building she added to the tinkerbelle/pixie hollow canon. I also loved the characters....except whenever the author made Clarion vacilulate on Milori, which was only added for third act break up drama 🙄.
Spoilers ahead - but only if you haven't seen secret of the wings movie
I think the real issue was that it was bound by the secret of the wings story. The fact that Clarion has to make a rule forbidding winter and summer fairies from crossing the border completely undermined her character growth in this story.
Spoilers ahead for the book....
her entire reasoning was stupid. She said she wouldn't be able to concentrate on her people, because she'd choose milori's benefit each time is so dumb. Like...parents juggle their relationship and kids and still make it work. A mature relationship knows that sometimes it takes a back seat to the needs of others. It was literally the dumbest reason ever, and it destroyed Clarion's character growth completely.
The worst part though was that the author ended it on a sad note. The author should have made an epilogue that took place after/during the secret of the wings movie. Maybe she didn't want to spoil it? But no one is going to pick up this up not having seen the movie. It's a non-smut fairy story for crying out loud; no non-fan is going to read it.
I was 10% in and there was already anti-catholicism and a guy assaulted her. I don't *think* she was raped, but she got knocked out as she was running, which is a) really hard to do and b) incredibly vulnerable, and the author just....doesn't touch on it.
It's also a Christian book, and so full of "and then this specific Bible verse came to her mind and she felt peace." And like...ok, maybe for some people that works, but in my experience that's misleading at best and disillusioning at worst for those who don't hear from God in that manner.
I characterized the one guy lunging for her as SA, because from context that's what it appeared to be. Also, reading though some of the reviews makes me suspicious that this might happen again, and I think SOMEONE should have the decency to tag it.
Cute story, and I liked how she incorporated the various aspects of the fairy tale. I did find it sad however, because growing up the 12 dancing princesses was always full of magic and wonder, and this didn't have that.