You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.
Take a photo of a barcode or cover
4.03 AVERAGE
4.03 AVERAGE
Reread/relisten November 2022
Same rating as thoughts as last time! I loved these two and how Tiller was so supportive of Mikey! These two are just so perfect together
4-4.5 stars-March 2022
Low relationship angst but the external factors aka the Coach was annoying.
But I really liked both Mikey and Tiller, they were great together and their personalities meshed perfectly!
This is a great winter book, so glad I read it on a warm spring day haha
I’ve seen mixed reviews on Truman’s book but I really like Sam when we saw snippets of him in this book.
Same rating as thoughts as last time! I loved these two and how Tiller was so supportive of Mikey! These two are just so perfect together
4-4.5 stars-March 2022
Low relationship angst but the external factors aka the Coach was annoying.
But I really liked both Mikey and Tiller, they were great together and their personalities meshed perfectly!
This is a great winter book, so glad I read it on a warm spring day haha
I’ve seen mixed reviews on Truman’s book but I really like Sam when we saw snippets of him in this book.
I looove pining. And this is a great book for that. The conflict with Mikey's father takes too much space in the story, which makes the story feel longer than what it actually is. Also, the epilogue from another character is a pet peeve of mine.
This could've been better. Maybe if I read it instead of listening. Both characters sounded ANNOYING as hell. And Mikey was just unlikeable. I can't put my finger on it.
You can tell this series has great potential. But sometimes it's hit and miss. This was a miss unfortunately
You can tell this series has great potential. But sometimes it's hit and miss. This was a miss unfortunately
Story if Mikey and Tiller
I loved, loved, loved this book!
Both Mikey and Tiller were adorable and they had such big caring hearts. So happy they r their hea.
I would have liked to have seen more about the relationship Mikey’s dad, and hoping it comes up in the next book as it felt a little unfinished there.
I loved, loved, loved this book!
Both Mikey and Tiller were adorable and they had such big caring hearts. So happy they r their hea.
I would have liked to have seen more about the relationship Mikey’s dad, and hoping it comes up in the next book as it felt a little unfinished there.
Intriguing start, likeable characters, nice romance and dialogues are full of intelligent banter.
But the end was rushed, illogical and pretty much unclear. You are kept completely wondering what the outcome is (except for the romance) without an actual cliffhanger. As if the author forgot to finish her story lines.
But the end was rushed, illogical and pretty much unclear. You are kept completely wondering what the outcome is (except for the romance) without an actual cliffhanger. As if the author forgot to finish her story lines.
funny
hopeful
inspiring
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
Complicated
Loveable characters:
Yes
emotional
funny
hopeful
lighthearted
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
After finishing the Made Marian and Wilde series, I was excited to start a new one by this author, but this first book disappointed me a little. I enjoyed very much the prequel, but I found this book a bit too slow, the end was too quick and I have the impression of “non-finished”. While at some points I had the impression of having too much details and not enough “action”, I craved for more story around the resolution. I really really did not like that epilogue was not about the MC but setting up the story for next book.
Tiller is the first openly out American Football player and, when he was first signed, he was forced to hire Mikey (his Coach's son) as a private chef. They both decided to that this situation was only for a short period of time. That was five years ago, and the two have grown to like and respect each other (and have crushes on each other). So when Tiller gets an injury and needs time to recover, Mikey puts his foot down and makes the pair go away to a private cabin in Aster Valley over Christmas.
One night, they cross the line and decide that whatever this is can only happen in Aster Valley. But what happens when the real world comes knocking? And what happens when Mikey's dad find out? Will they call time on their relationship or will they realise there's more to life than American Football?
I've realised from the past 12 or so months that I don't really like romances to have too much angst. No angst or very little. So, going into this blind, I wasn't sure which way this was going to go.
I did enjoy this, once I found my footing. I did like Mikey and Tiller apart and together. I love the idea of friends to lovers in a holiday bubble situation. No angst here, just them enjoying each other company and then them kissing and making friends with the people in town. The fact that, up to a pop, they talked and respected each other, was a big thing for me. I really liked this chunk of the book.
However, once people outside of Aster Valley began to find out (aka Mikey's Dad - who he has to call Coach [why would you demand you children to call you your job title and not Dad or Father is beyond me? He has a huge power complex]), the angst and angry came in. The fact that we see/are told that Mikey's family are quite neglectful to him is upsetting (I see why this was here - found family troupe are a lovely thing and I did enjoy that Mikey finds his family in Tiller's family and in the residents of Aster Valley), but to have Coach blackmail Mikey to leave so that he'll bench a still-injured Tiller for a game or two and allow Mikey to publish a cookbook with NFL players quotes used angered me. To choose a sport over your child upset me no end. I was waiting for Coach to face some kind of justice or consequence and yet... nothing.
So, I don't deal with angst well. Which probably explains why I am not going anywhere near the second book in the series, [b:Sweet as Honey|56714714|Sweet as Honey (Aster Valley, #2)|Lucy Lennox|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1616600822l/56714714._SY75_.jpg|88665381], as after read the blurb for it and several write-ups, it's not going to work for me. Nope. Not going to go down that rabbit hole.
Speaking of book 2 in the series, can I talk about the epilogue super quick? I agree with everyone else - the epilogue doesn't work. It took away from the "Happily Ever After" we got in the final chapter with Tiller and Mikey. Plus, the epilogue works as a first chapter to the next book in the series, or a taster for the next book (something I don't think anyone wanted). I get why this decision was made to have one half of the couple from next book do the epilogue - teases us to get book 2 and hints of the mystery/angst for the couple yo come - but no. It didn't tease me into getting book two. In fact, it made me decide not to (which is sad as quite intrigued by this coupling [one half more than the other]) , but reading this made me go "Nope" as I don't think I could stand reading from this person's POV. This character lack self-confidence and I have a horrible feeling that the "damsel in distress" troupe will be used HEAVILY and, while I do like the "damsel/saviour" troupe, I want the couple to be equals to each other, not have one save the other constantly due to power complex.
So no to Sweet as Honey. I might consider [b:Hot as Heller|57590880|Hot as Heller (Aster Valley, #3)|Lucy Lennox|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1621103647l/57590880._SX50_.jpg|90192024] or the prequel novella, [b:Winter Waites|56403174|Winter Waites (Aster Valley #0.5)|Lucy Lennox|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1608848928l/56403174._SY75_.jpg|87894484], if I do decide to return to this world.
Another thing that did annoy me is that, if you're doing dual narrative on an audiobook, maybe have two narrators as, at times, the voice got muddled and kept going "Wait, who's chapter is this?". I get why (if self-published, funds are tight), but there were one or two choices made with characters's voice that made me wince every now and again. But the narrator, Michael Dean, is well-known and well respected narrator in the MM romance (my first outing) so might be a tad harsh on this front. I, recently, listened to an interview with him on a podcast and it made really interesting listening (link for that is here).
I glad I tried this as want to read more MM romances, but not sure this author's style is for me. May come back to this series, maybe not. I do have more exploring in this genre to do before I make my decision.
***This review will be on The Pewter Wolf Reads sometime in mid-to-late June 2021***
One night, they cross the line and decide that whatever this is can only happen in Aster Valley. But what happens when the real world comes knocking? And what happens when Mikey's dad find out? Will they call time on their relationship or will they realise there's more to life than American Football?
I've realised from the past 12 or so months that I don't really like romances to have too much angst. No angst or very little. So, going into this blind, I wasn't sure which way this was going to go.
I did enjoy this, once I found my footing. I did like Mikey and Tiller apart and together. I love the idea of friends to lovers in a holiday bubble situation. No angst here, just them enjoying each other company and then them kissing and making friends with the people in town. The fact that, up to a pop, they talked and respected each other, was a big thing for me. I really liked this chunk of the book.
However, once people outside of Aster Valley began to find out (aka Mikey's Dad - who he has to call Coach [why would you demand you children to call you your job title and not Dad or Father is beyond me? He has a huge power complex]), the angst and angry came in. The fact that we see/are told that Mikey's family are quite neglectful to him is upsetting (I see why this was here - found family troupe are a lovely thing and I did enjoy that Mikey finds his family in Tiller's family and in the residents of Aster Valley), but to have Coach blackmail Mikey to leave so that he'll bench a still-injured Tiller for a game or two and allow Mikey to publish a cookbook with NFL players quotes used angered me. To choose a sport over your child upset me no end. I was waiting for Coach to face some kind of justice or consequence and yet... nothing.
So, I don't deal with angst well. Which probably explains why I am not going anywhere near the second book in the series, [b:Sweet as Honey|56714714|Sweet as Honey (Aster Valley, #2)|Lucy Lennox|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1616600822l/56714714._SY75_.jpg|88665381], as after read the blurb for it and several write-ups, it's not going to work for me. Nope. Not going to go down that rabbit hole.
Speaking of book 2 in the series, can I talk about the epilogue super quick? I agree with everyone else - the epilogue doesn't work. It took away from the "Happily Ever After" we got in the final chapter with Tiller and Mikey. Plus, the epilogue works as a first chapter to the next book in the series, or a taster for the next book (something I don't think anyone wanted). I get why this decision was made to have one half of the couple from next book do the epilogue - teases us to get book 2 and hints of the mystery/angst for the couple yo come - but no. It didn't tease me into getting book two. In fact, it made me decide not to (which is sad as quite intrigued by this coupling [one half more than the other]) , but reading this made me go "Nope" as I don't think I could stand reading from this person's POV. This character lack self-confidence and I have a horrible feeling that the "damsel in distress" troupe will be used HEAVILY and, while I do like the "damsel/saviour" troupe, I want the couple to be equals to each other, not have one save the other constantly due to power complex.
So no to Sweet as Honey. I might consider [b:Hot as Heller|57590880|Hot as Heller (Aster Valley, #3)|Lucy Lennox|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1621103647l/57590880._SX50_.jpg|90192024] or the prequel novella, [b:Winter Waites|56403174|Winter Waites (Aster Valley #0.5)|Lucy Lennox|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1608848928l/56403174._SY75_.jpg|87894484], if I do decide to return to this world.
Another thing that did annoy me is that, if you're doing dual narrative on an audiobook, maybe have two narrators as, at times, the voice got muddled and kept going "Wait, who's chapter is this?". I get why (if self-published, funds are tight), but there were one or two choices made with characters's voice that made me wince every now and again. But the narrator, Michael Dean, is well-known and well respected narrator in the MM romance (my first outing) so might be a tad harsh on this front. I, recently, listened to an interview with him on a podcast and it made really interesting listening (link for that is here).
I glad I tried this as want to read more MM romances, but not sure this author's style is for me. May come back to this series, maybe not. I do have more exploring in this genre to do before I make my decision.
***This review will be on The Pewter Wolf Reads sometime in mid-to-late June 2021***
emotional
funny
lighthearted
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Complicated
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Complicated
Content Warnings
Graphic: Sexual content, Injury/Injury detail
Moderate: Homophobia
Toxic parents