Scan barcode
ogreart's review against another edition
5.0
I am a major fan of Doctor Who. Have been ever since the fourth Doctor was playing on PBS back in the 80's. When the series came back a few years ago, I was very happy and the stories were all topnotch. This graphic novel is full of terrific stories (if not always terrific art). The tenth Doctor's personality shines through clearly. And that personality made reading this book a lot of fun.
zoes_human's review
2.0
A collection of six single stories featuring the tenth Doctor. The art was overall disappointing, and the stories, while fine, were not terribly interesting with the exception of Rich Johnston's Room with a Déjà View. It was nice to have two more Martha Jones stories; however, given her prominence on the cover, I had actually expected her to be featured throughout.
writertomg's review against another edition
3.0
Good stories with The Doctor alone, with Martha, and with Donna. Lots of shout-outs to the original series (specifically Tom Baker and Leela). The illustration of the first story was not to my liking, but the others were well drawn. All the stories were good overall and all seemed to capture the patter and spirit of Tennant's Doctor. A nice read for Doctor Who fans.
nwhyte's review against another edition
3.0
http://nwhyte.livejournal.com/1365198.html
a nice half-dozen Tenth Doctor stories, originally published as separate comics and here as a single volume by IDW. I really bought it to read the first story, "The Whispering Gallery", which is by Leah and John, and am glad to say that I enjoyed it and most of the others (the exception being a typically cliched cute robot story in the middle). The standout, however, is Tony Lee's "The Time Machination", featuring Ten teaming up with H.G. Wells against Torchwood, with lots of other pleasing references to both New and particularly Old Who. Lee's The Forgotten was also excellent, and I shall look out for more of his work. And the collection as a whole is excellent value.
a nice half-dozen Tenth Doctor stories, originally published as separate comics and here as a single volume by IDW. I really bought it to read the first story, "The Whispering Gallery", which is by Leah and John, and am glad to say that I enjoyed it and most of the others (the exception being a typically cliched cute robot story in the middle). The standout, however, is Tony Lee's "The Time Machination", featuring Ten teaming up with H.G. Wells against Torchwood, with lots of other pleasing references to both New and particularly Old Who. Lee's The Forgotten was also excellent, and I shall look out for more of his work. And the collection as a whole is excellent value.
larrys's review
3.0
I know a few people who love Doctor Who but I've never really known what it's all about. I even googled: 'basic premise of doctor who' and came up with something like 'Doctor Who is an alien in the shape of a man from earth, and with his sidekick he travels to different times and places and basically walks around until he finds some sort of trouble to get out of.'
There's also something about a 'tardis', a 'sonic screwdriver' and for some reason he says 'allons-y' all the time in this one. I had to look that up, too. Now I'm fluent in French.
There's also something about a 'tardis', a 'sonic screwdriver' and for some reason he says 'allons-y' all the time in this one. I had to look that up, too. Now I'm fluent in French.
noveladdiction's review
3.0
Loved the different art styles.. and I miss my Tennant! A girl never forgets her first Doctor <3
More...