1.16k reviews for:

The Crowns of Croswald

D.E. Night

3.62 AVERAGE


What an exciting start to a magical series!! Night does an amazing job of transporting you into the land of Croswald. You’ll be rooting for Ivy from the very beginning. The story has all the magic any young Harry Potter fan could want with more than enough fantasy to keep you hooked throughout! The necessity of any truly wonderful book is the feeling of being sucked into the story and not wanting to return to reality. That is what D. E. Night has accomplished here! I can’t wait to read the next installment in the Croswald series and lose myself in this amazing world all over again.

As much as I enjoyed the character building and magical content of The Crowns of Croswald, I did find certain events and monologues cliche. It rings familiar with a few other magical good vs evil stories and I was a little disappointed there wasn’t as much character development or world building as I would like however what there was I did enjoy.


InstagramTiktokBlog

Thank you to Stories Untold Press for providing me with an e-arc in exchange for an honest review

I enjoyed it but I don't think Middle Grade Fantasy interests me anymore :'). Ivy was a really interesting character and I loved the mystery that surrounded her existence. I have a soft spot for boarding school type settings so that was great! I don't think it spoke to me but if I read this in Middle School I would have loved it. Highly recommend! <3

Things I liked:
- simple story
- great world building
- interesting plot

The Crowns of Croswald
Author: D.E. Night

I was asked by the publisher of this book series to write an review in exchange for a free Ebook.

The Crowns of Croswald is the first book in the The Crowns of Croswald series.

We meet Ivy Lovely who is our main character. Ivy lives a lonely live for a sixteen year old girl. Her life isn't special at all and her work as a scaldrony maid bores her. Suddenly sparkles of magic shine bright into Ivy her life. New paths introduce the young Ivy to a new magical world.

Magical surprises follow each other in rapid succession. Ivy get introduced to the lifestyle on a magical school named: The Walls of Ivy.

When the evil Queen threatens Ivy, her mission is to save her loved ones.
Can Ivy withstand all the secrets of her family tree?

The Crowns of Croswald is a middle grade fantasy series for childeren. I think that this series is very suitable for children above 10 years old. Not because it includes any aggressive topics, but the storyline can be a bit difficult to follow at some specific points.

I admire all the fantasy characters, and the world building.
At some points I found that the story shared to much similarities compared to Harry Potter. This distracted me from the storyline because it made me compare the both of them. I missed some originality.

I want to thank the publisher and the author for the free Ebook.

First can I just say I fell in love with the illustrations in this book. The covers are gorgeous and that continues throughout the book. So on to the book, as a Harry Potter fan I really enjoyed all the magic elements included in it as well as how the author added in elements of steampunk. I love Ivy and her journey and I flew through this book. I will say that sometimes I did feel confused since some threads would just stop. Left me questioning whether the author forgot the characters goals. That said that was really my only issue.

dmatson21's review

3.0
adventurous lighthearted relaxing fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: No

I loved this book! I really enjoyed the word of Croswald. The story is part Harry Potter and part Cinderella, but D.E. Night has absolutely made it her own. She has imagined a world quite unlike anything I’ve read before, and I can’t wait to continue it with the next book!
adventurous lighthearted fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

Thank you to the Author and Publisher for giving me this free book in exchange for an honest review.

A girl, Ivy, lives as a maid in a castle that has beautiful slurry fields where she sometimes meets her friend that is a dwarf while she enjoys sketching. One day she is kicked out for stuff that isn't even her fault, along with a dragon that had gotten sick (a temporary illness like a cold) that ends up being like a pet to her, she is almost 16, and she gets picked up by people that had been looking for her, because of her magical blood, in a flying carriage to go off to the Halls of Ivy to hone her skills as a scrivenist, in a town that as an evil Dark Queen for a ruler.

I ended up reading this entire book with a migraine, which I still have. Not because of the book, I think it's the changing seasons but i'm not sure. If I hadn't had said migraine I could have finished this book in 2-3 days. It's a light middle grade fantasy read, full of magic, adventure, and danger! So that may have clouded my enjoyment a bit.

It started off a bit slow for me. It does have the trope early on of an ugly woman with an ugly personality to match, even saying "Perhaps her horrid personality had seeped out and shaped her appearance." Yes, I really enjoyed this book but I always try to mention stuff I liked and didn't like in reviews. Maybe this is a me thing but i'm getting tired of seeing, especially in middle grade books where it seems to be most common, (from what i've seen), an ugly or disfigured person being evil or an asshole, as if someone's appearance and personality have to match. There was also a bit of talk about bodily emissions that, due to personal medical issues, I didn't quite appreciate. However all this is early in the book and doesn't last long.

It did pick up and I really enjoyed the rest of the book. It reminded me a bit of Harry Potter, in all the right ways, while still being different and standing on it's own! It did have some nice messages through-out the book too that I really did appreciate. The writing was easy to read and flowed well for me. I really enjoyed Ivy once I got to know her. She hasn't had an easy life but she is a nice girl, with a bit of a rebellious and stubborn side to her which I frankly loved! She knows people are keeping stuff about her from her and she is determined to find answers that she deserves to have about herself! I did enjoy the friendships in the book too and hope to see more of them in future books.

I loved the magic system in the book, no wands are needed! I did also enjoy the world-building, though I do still have some questions but the way it leaves off i'm assuming there is going to be more books, and if so hopefully we'll get some answers in them. I can't stop wondering if the hairies, little fairy creatures in lanterns used as lights, enjoy being used in that way, are they happy like that? How did that come about?

There was a twist that I loved and, personally I didn't see coming, but someone more read in fantasy might? I have no idea, but I enjoyed it just the same! Getting to figure out what secrets were being kept. There is still danger for the town, in the form of the Dark Queen that rules the place, and someone that betrayed Ivy and the school that is still unknown who it is. I have my guesses but will just have to wait for the next book to see if any of them are right!

It's truly a tale that gets more magical and exciting as you read with secrets being revealed through-out the story. If you enjoy middle grade fantasy with magic, adventure, secrets, rule-breaking, and an evil Queen in power i'd definitely recommend checking this out! 
melissasbookshelf's profile picture

melissasbookshelf's review

3.0

The Crowns of Croswald is a fun fantasy series for middle grade readers. It is quite similar to Harry Potter in many aspects, yet it has its own unique world and brand of magic. Like Harry Potter, Ivy is a young woman who has grown up in humble circumstances. She is treated poorly at the Castle Plum where she works as a scaldrony maid who cares for the dragons that heat the ovens of the castle. When she receives a mysterious invitation to attend a magical school, the Halls of Ivy, she begins a fantastical journey of discovering more about her true origins, meeting loyal friends, and encountering bullies, as well as a nasty villain.

Though the general story arc has similarities to Harry Potter, there are also differences that make it unique. First, the magical system is different. Royalty uses stones in crowns to make magic and then there are the scriveners who work for the royal families and use their quills to create magic. There are all sorts of magical creatures who live in this world, like haries (fairy like creatures who basically live in lanterns and provide the light). There are also some unusual locations like the Hollow Shaft that appears out of the water and disappears almost as quickly, as well as worlds within bottles called glanageries. There is a school master called the Selector who is a sort of Dumbledore figure, but is much more mysterious and it’s unclear whose side she is on. There is also an evil Queen who is followed around by her evil minions called the Cloaked Brood.

As a reader, this magical world was somewhat confusing. I felt like I was plunged into the world without much explanation. I think including a map of the world and also a glossary at the back containing information on the magic, money system, food, characters, etc. would have been extremely helpful.

There was plenty of action in this story and uses of magic. The one problem that I kept having was seeing a connection between events. It seemed a little disjointed and I wanted a bit more of an explanation for what was happening before being plunged into something else. It was because of this that it took me awhile to get into the book. I feel like if I read it a second time, I would find it more enjoyable because then I would better understand the world and see the connections knowing what’s coming.

I really enjoyed the side characters. I liked Fyn and Rebecca especially and I wished that they were explored more than they were. Unfortunately, I had a difficult time liking the main character Ivy. She seemed too self absorbed and cared little about how her actions affected her friends and other people. For instance, her friend Rebecca gets stuck in this forgotten room. Ivy knows where she is, but does little to try to rescue her from the situation. She involves Fyn in a scheme when leaving the school only to put him in grave danger with little thought to him. Hopefully, she becomes more likable and her character develops more in the next books.

All in all, I liked this book. I think Harry Potter fans who love the story and enjoy characters with a somewhat similar arc will enjoy this book. I recognize that I’m not the target audience for this book, but I think middle grade readers will like the magical world. This would be a good adventure to introduce them to the fantasy genre. I wavered between 3 and 4 stars, but ultimately went with three because of the issues previously discussed. I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author and NetGalley for my honest review. All opinions are my own and I was not required to give a positive review.