Scan barcode
thomasray's review against another edition
4.0
Still dark, still pretty good, still a little more dramatic than nescessary.... I liked it. Erin Hunter is apparently fine with explaining baboon brutality, down to the flinging aside of every "bloody body" as well as describing both cannibalistic lions and wild dogs who hunt animals to only eat their hearts.
Throughout most of the book I was just thinking how many problems would be fixed if the characters would just think for one minute longer. It's frustrating!
It is still a good book, though. Mostly because of nostalgia, I think...
Throughout most of the book I was just thinking how many problems would be fixed if the characters would just think for one minute longer. It's frustrating!
It is still a good book, though. Mostly because of nostalgia, I think...
shannonf60e7's review against another edition
4.0
I enjoyed this one a lot! It was so action packed and I liked how some things turned out to be, I must say there were a lot of things I didn’t see coming. Now that I finished this book, I do wonder what will happen next and how the story will progress.
theravenflight's review against another edition
3.0
Seemed like a filler
After all the excitement of the previous book, this one just seemed like filler.
Literally all that happened in this book was everyone running away. Sky ran from her herd, Thorn ran from his troop, and Fearless disowned his own Pride for some reason...
I really enjoy the change from domestic animals to wild animals in Erin Hunter novels, and I just hope the books that follow pick up more. I would hate for this series to end at just six books.
After all the excitement of the previous book, this one just seemed like filler.
I really enjoy the change from domestic animals to wild animals in Erin Hunter novels, and I just hope the books that follow pick up more. I would hate for this series to end at just six books.
More...