1.15k reviews for:

Meaty

Samantha Irby

3.83 AVERAGE


When she's on, Samantha Irby is tears-streaming-down-your-face funny. Some of the essays in this book hit that mark, and some miss. I don't totally understand the way the essays are organized, but I LOVE the way she writes recipes.

cisium's review

4.25
funny lighthearted sad
milliebot_reads's profile picture

milliebot_reads's review

4.5
emotional funny fast-paced

frencholina's review

5.0

Messaging: 5/5
Character development: N/A
Plot: N/A
Interest: 5/5
Writing style: 5/5
Comments: brilliant. brought up a rainbow of emotions

livelyghost's review

2.5
funny medium-paced

Often bridged too far into complaint territory for me, but damn if some of her passages about the relationship between sex and self-validation didn’t hit home for me. If you liked the writing style of tumblr blogs in 2014 you’ll like this. 
emotional funny lighthearted medium-paced

some good recipes in there!!

I laughed! I almost cried! I mostly laughed!

I love Samantha Irby and feel as though I just read a book by a close friend.

The amount of all caps, lists, and frantic rhetorical questions reads just like the inside of my brain and I feel like each essay was a different lunch date with someone I’ve known forever and maybe have a small crush on.

kathleenlouiseg's review

4.5
funny lighthearted medium-paced
anainthemargins's profile picture

anainthemargins's review

2.75
challenging emotional funny slow-paced

I read Samantha Irby's books out of order. That was a mistake (or the perfect choice).

Where "We are Never Meeting in Real Life" was hilarious, violently crude, full of rage (which is a complement), emotionally revealing, and intensely vulnerable, "Meaty" was just crude and pretty funny. I feel like I would have enjoyed Meaty more if I had not had the expectations that We are Never Meeting in Real Life gave me about her writing.

Or else the overwhelming sense of self-hatred disguised as self-knowledge combined with a sort of empty crudeness in Meaty would have turned me away forever. I am not sure which.