Scan barcode
bloodyfool0's review against another edition
4.0
Very good work by the authors in presenting a voluminous work containing numerous interviews, reviews and commentary. It makes for surprisingly easy read.
The protest movement was a difficult period for HK with the media continuously devoting loads of time on the subject. This book recounts much of what transpired and also adds interviews and commentary. This book is neither a "blue" nor "yellow" colour, but one that attempts to take a holistic view of the subject.
I was at first apprehensive of reading seeing that SCMP published the piece, however, I am glad I did as it brings some fresh material into view.
With the advent of the securities law about to be enacted, this may not be the end of the movement but perhaps the end of an era. This book, I believe helps understand some of the reasons for the unrest and concerns of the people of HK.
The protest movement was a difficult period for HK with the media continuously devoting loads of time on the subject. This book recounts much of what transpired and also adds interviews and commentary. This book is neither a "blue" nor "yellow" colour, but one that attempts to take a holistic view of the subject.
I was at first apprehensive of reading seeing that SCMP published the piece, however, I am glad I did as it brings some fresh material into view.
With the advent of the securities law about to be enacted, this may not be the end of the movement but perhaps the end of an era. This book, I believe helps understand some of the reasons for the unrest and concerns of the people of HK.
harius_b's review against another edition
2.0
***1.5 out of 5 stars***
A disappointing book. Regardless of what one may say, this was a horribly edited text. If it was well handled, the final product would not have been larger than half its current size. The only good thing this book will offer its readers is a multifaceted analysis of the 2019 HK protest movement. However, the experience was absolutely terrible. I caution anyone lacking in patience to avoid this book, and if not, treat it strictly as a reference book. It is not meant for straight forward and pleasant reading.
A disappointing book. Regardless of what one may say, this was a horribly edited text. If it was well handled, the final product would not have been larger than half its current size. The only good thing this book will offer its readers is a multifaceted analysis of the 2019 HK protest movement. However, the experience was absolutely terrible. I caution anyone lacking in patience to avoid this book, and if not, treat it strictly as a reference book. It is not meant for straight forward and pleasant reading.
otaku10's review
informative
reflective
medium-paced
5.0
A very thorough and unbiased look at the social unrest in Hong Kong since 2019. Not only does it discuss the protest movement and its opposition, but it looks at the events that preceeded the protests, opinions of both mainlanders, foreigners, and Hong Kongers not involved in the unrest. Asks great questions while providing a myriad of opinions and solutions from all sides. All information is well documented and I enjoyed the supplemental material in the back of the book as well.
More...